4 ms·
This reminds me of some deeply troubling things I've read about the education systems in China and Japan, where students are heavily burdened and stressed, and
by javajosh 12y ago
This reminds me of some deeply troubling things I've read about the education systems in China and Japan, where students are heavily burdened and stressed, and suicide rates are also high.
The problem unique to the West is 'do your best' doublespeak. There is a real, objective standard that, if kids do not meet it, means they will live a materially worse life. Their prospects at virtually every level, personal and professional, will be reduced. Effort is not actually what our kids need to be elite: admission to an ivy league school is, and that means objective achievement.
Preparation for admission requires ever increasing levels of achievement, where achievement means "fewer and fewer mistakes" approaching an asymptote of no mistakes, ever. This pressure apparently starts to kick in around 6th grade.
Maintaining that kind of consistency is itself a very real burden, no matter what age, activity or the difficulty of the task. Imagine being told that, as long as you press a button every hour for 8 hours a day, for 4 years, you'll get 20 million dollars. If you miss once, you get 10M, twice 1M and three times, 0. Would this create a healthy psychology, or would it be stressful?
- nitrogen 12y agoMaintaining that kind of consistency is itself a very real burden, no matter what age, activity or the difficulty of the task. Imagine being told that, as long as you press a button every hour for 8 hours a day, for 4 years, you'll get 20 million dollars. If you miss once, you get 10M, twice 1M and three times, 0. Would this create a healthy psychology, or would it be stressful? Sounds kind of like the Lost scenario, where failing to push a button will destroy the world. It certainly did not result in a healthy psychology in the show. I always wondered why they didn't just rig up a machine to push the button (and type in the numbers) for them.