2 ms·
"They" is a big net to cast. I know a lot of people who were involved and don't even have twitter accounts - would you cast it over those too? I don't think I
by scrollaway 12y ago
"They" is a big net to cast. I know a lot of people who were involved and don't even have twitter accounts - would you cast it over those too?
I don't think I saw a focus on how "those girls were sleeping to the top" over the more general issue of "look at how those guys would trade sex for undisclosed favours".
- PhasmaFelis 12y ago> I don't think I saw a focus on how "those girls were sleeping to the top" over the more general issue of "look at how those guys would trade sex for undisclosed favours". I want to be perfectly clear, though, that neither of those things ever happened. The story that various writers accepted sex from Zoe Quinn in exchange for good reviews was the founding event of the Gamergate movement, and it is 100% false.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- scrollaway 12y agoNot that you have any sources for that, but either way, does it matter? I don't know about you, but I don't really care about Quinn (her sex life even less so), and IMO everyone involved (on both sides) should stop caring about her - she, and some other nameless people, have been using the controversy as their personal publicity ring. Fact is, I can tell you first hand that the industry I'm in is massively corrupt. I'm glad some people are casting a light on it. Devs, journalists, indies, companies, it's rotten all over. Full of people abused for working their "dream job", full of undisclosed deals to promote such and such game (makes sense when your livelyhood literally depends on it)... and full of seriously low quality wannabe-journalism to top it all. I love what I do, but god damn do I hate the environment I do it in.
- PhasmaFelis 12y ago> Not that you have any sources for that As a matter of fact! Eron Gjoni accused Quinn of sleeping with 5 guys, whom he named. (http://gamergate.wikia.com/wiki/5_guys http://gamergate.wikia.com/wiki/5_guys) Four of these guys were game designers, not journalists. Nathan Grayson was the only journalist among them, and he mentioned Quinn and her game exactly twice, in passing in larger articles--one for Rock Paper Shotgun in January, one for Kotaku in March. (http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2014/01/08/admission-quest-valve-greenlights-50-more-games/ http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2014/01/08/admission-quest-v..., http://kotaku.com/in-recent-days-ive-been-asked-several-times-about-a-pos-1624707346 http://kotaku.com/in-recent-days-ive-been-asked-several-time...) Gjoni himself says that Grayson and Quinn didn't sleep together until April at least. (http://geekparty.com/eron-gjoni-clarifies-the-zoe-quinn-nathan-grayson-timeline/ http://geekparty.com/eron-gjoni-clarifies-the-zoe-quinn-nath...) So, yes, the idea that Quinn traded sex for reviews is provably, definitively a lie, and all of this information has been publicly available for around nine months. > but either way, does it matter? Yes, the truth matters, especially when lies are being used to harass someone. This is exactly what I was talking about in my original snarkpost. You're absolutely right that the gaming press is full of corruption, and has been for as long as there's been a gaming press, but gamers in general have never given two shits. Remember when Jeff Gerstmann got fired from GameSpot for giving Kane & Lynch a 6/10, and the bloggers tutted over it for a week, and then everybody forgot? It wasn't half as controversial as, say, that time the CODBLOPS tutorial level was too hand-holdy. Who cared if some guy lost his job? The games kept coming, and that was all that mattered. But when a woman is accused (falsely) of using sex to boost sales of her (free) indie game, oh ho ho, now it's time for a fucking movement. THIS INJUSTICE SHALL NOT STAND. And when you show these guys incontrovertible evidence that the accusation against Quinn was a lie, then they immediately backpedal and say it was never really about Quinn, and go right back to raging about Anita Sarkeesian and Brianna Wu and ignoring guys like Gerstmann. There are people who've aligned themselves with Gamergate who actually care about ethics in game journalism, and it's a damn shame, because Gamergate is rooted in lies. If you really want to do something about corruption, don't do it while riding the coattails of a "movement" that was only ever a wildly-successful troll.
- scrollaway 12y agoThanks for the sources. > There are people who've aligned themselves with Gamergate who actually care about ethics in game journalism, and it's a damn shame, because Gamergate is rooted in lies. If you really want to do something about corruption, don't do it while riding the coattails of a "movement" that was only ever a wildly-successful troll. If you look in my post history, you'll find that I said exactly this a few months back. I'm convinced that Gamergate's #1 problem is how the name is reused for everything and based on a hashtag (which makes it easy to abuse as a "dialing my personal army" kind of thing). Twitter doesn't allow for intelligent discourse anyway, and encourages this kind of "us vs. them" mentality. (Maybe you're familiar with CGPGrey's video on it, if not, I very highly recommend it: http://www.cgpgrey.com/blog/this-video-will-make-you-angry http://www.cgpgrey.com/blog/this-video-will-make-you-angry) The tipping point that boosted GG's popularity wasn't specifically the Quinn scandal but the onslaught of "gamers are dead" article, which was followed by more and more revelations (and I'm sure a fair share of them were false). The Quinn scandal was one starting point, but it could have been anything else. But does it matter what started a movement, really? Because right now, the controversy's is fueled by the people who stand to gain the most from the attention. Quinn is the least guilty of it, but if you look close enough, you'll find that the harrassment claims are really just claims. Just the other day, one of those recurring names was claiming she had to "flee to Europe because of the threats", and then when few-months older tweets surfaced about a "planned vacation to Europe" surfaced, the narrative changed. (Again, I apologise for no sources but I dislike giving those people attention - my email is accessible from my profile if you want to continue in private). I'm sure they get their fair share of death threats but... don't be on twitter then? It's not just a horrible medium for discussion, it really encourages this behaviour. Anyone mildly popular and controversial gets death threats. Just like anyone mildly rich will find people asking for money. I try to remain neutral, as I said. But it's hard to feel sympathy for those people. The only thing that can be done about corruption is that people find out and talk about it, and that won't happen without momentum. GG just happens to have the momentum.