4 ms·
Gamergate in a nutshell: A: "Games journalism is being corrupted by woman-centered bias. Here's the damning proof: This guy says his ex-girlfriend repeatedly t
by PhasmaFelis 12y ago
Gamergate in a nutshell:
A: "Games journalism is being corrupted by woman-centered bias. Here's the damning proof: This guy says his ex-girlfriend repeatedly traded sex for positive reviews of her game."
B: "That is provably untrue."
A: "Yes, okay, that was a lie. Why are you so hung up on that when the real issue is that women are ruining games journalism?"
- Karunamon 12y agoThat's not even close to being fair. Try http://deepfreeze.it http://deepfreeze.it - complete with citations for pretty mcuh everything.
- scrollaway 12y agoWhat really hurts me reading this post is that you either don't know anything about a very controversial situation and still felt qualified to "explain things in a nutshell", or you are very clearly on one side (and consequently know a lot more than you let on) and felt the need to lie. So.. why?
- throwaway161605 12y agoDo better.
- scrollaway 12y agoIt's sad you made a throwaway just to be able to downvote me. On HN of all places. Kind of ruins your credibility, doesn't it?
- throwaway161605 12y agoa) If I chose to exercise my main account here, there's nothing that would prevent me from downvoting. There would be no need to create a new account. Even trying to wouldn't make sense because... b) New accounts cannot downvote anybody. By operating here with an alt account instead of my main account, I give up my ability to downvote. Given A and B, your entire premise is totally messed up. c) It's sad that you've resorted twice to the "it's sad" shtick. The comment was a non-aggressive, good faith one. How about you not take it as an attack? How about you take it as a genuine request? How about you consider following through with the request on that token? Do better than that response, too.
- scrollaway 12y agoa+b) My apologies. You're right, I didn't mean "downvote". As for c... "Do better", what? "Do better" is not a valid comment. This is a valid comment, your previous one was not. Do you want me to explain what I said in further details? I thought it was self-explanatory. PhasmaFelis has decided to take an issue which is clearly controversial to even members not involved and "nutshell" it extremely disrespectuously. Much as it's petty twitter wars for some, it's also extremely serious issues for others. Jobs can be lost. Jobs have been lost. Some because of ethical concerns, corruption being unveiled etc. Some other jobs have been lost because random idiots decided to false-flag people to their companies until they got fired. Some have been lost because of out-of-context, selective quoting (hey, remember the PyCon forking drama? Yes, like that). So yes, it's sad that someone who is probably not involved further than the petty twitter wars would choose to either adopt such a dismissive and diminishing attitude, or would choose to lie to further whatever cause he may have had in mind. Edit: As for actual downvotes, there's some serious downvoting on actual discussion going on in this entire sub-thread. That, too, is sad.
- joshuapants 12y agoI find it telling that you've given an in-depth argument to something that is basically inconsequential but are afraid to actually address the topic at hand. Also, please spare us the Tumblr level "do better," unless of course you "can't even."
- k__ 12y agoI had the impression that game journalism is corrupted in general and the story (true or not) just brought this to medial attention. Which I found sexist, because those people got pampered by the game publishers all the time and no one cared...
- scrollaway 12y agoAs I said below, I work in the industry. And yes, it's extremely incestuous (not just games journalism... the entire non-mobile games industry). Corruption is rampant and until gamergate surfaced, nobody cared because "whatever, it's just games". > Which I found sexist Huh?
- k__ 12y agoWell, because they harassed that girl and were all about "look how those girls can sleep them to the top" blabla
- scrollaway 12y ago"They" is a big net to cast. I know a lot of people who were involved and don't even have twitter accounts - would you cast it over those too? I don't think I saw a focus on how "those girls were sleeping to the top" over the more general issue of "look at how those guys would trade sex for undisclosed favours".
- PhasmaFelis 12y ago> I don't think I saw a focus on how "those girls were sleeping to the top" over the more general issue of "look at how those guys would trade sex for undisclosed favours". I want to be perfectly clear, though, that neither of those things ever happened. The story that various writers accepted sex from Zoe Quinn in exchange for good reviews was the founding event of the Gamergate movement, and it is 100% false.
- deleted 12y ago
- hkon 12y agoI scrolled through a few articles on gamergate. I still don't get it. I got to this article, where someone apparently wrote a book "understand gamergate". So it seems to be a complex case. I've seen the term a few hundred times, but never sparked my interest. I recon'd by this time it would be easily summarized. But I guess not. Thanks for trying though.
- kristofferR 12y agoDon't bother, it's a classic dishonest flamewar where both sides does their best to smear the other side. Nobody cares about the issue anymore (they can't even agree on what the issue actually is).