7 ms·
Most children are happy, but material deprivation catches up eventually
- bigtones 12y agoCould it be that children are just happier than adults, regardless of their material assets. Adults have responsibilities and stresses that children do not - and that is probably more of a causation than their material assets.
- dnlrussell 12y agoChildren do have school though . . . Nothing makes me more unhappy than school.
- mhurron 12y agoThe only time I was happier than when I was at school was right after I was finished with school, unemployed and living at home. I could do what I wanted, when I wanted to do it. At school I could learn, as much as I could get my hands on. I was much happier at school than I am now that I have to work. I almost hit it when I take a day off for no reason.
- sukilot 12y agoMy (small) kids love school. School is very bad in USA and many other places, due to a bizarre set of constraints such as far too few teachers in budget.
- jes5199 12y agoI actually find responsibility to be a great source of joy and happiness, and remember my adolescence as unhappy because I didn't have thing that I had enough control over for them to be rewarding
- nostrademons 12y agoIt could also be that happiness is strongly dependent upon where you stand relative to the people around you. Children don't compare themselves to much other than the immediate family, village, or neighborhood; they just don't have the life experience to know how people in different cities throughout the rest of the world live. Adults have had time to absorb cultural messages of inferiority: these are all the things that your counterparts in America do that you're missing out on. (Never mind that the Hollywood messages broadcast around the globe tend to cherry-pick the most glamorous, outrageous lifestyles and display them as normal.) It takes a lot of deliberate mental practice to learn not to care about what others have or what they might think of you, and few people bother.
- Dewie3 12y agoI didn't care about things when I was a kid which I do care about now. The difference is that I learnt that some things are "better" than others. And I only care about those things from a place of fear of being deprived of things which people with those things can seemingly get more easily. Some of it boils down to worrying and fretting about things which I don't, or maybe even can't, change. This has no root in rationality or pragmatism, so the usual arguments of having to care about such things because of adult responsibilities and problem fixing don't apply. Another facet is that this caring is only a projection of what you think you will feel in the having, or not-having, of those things. But many people have experienced that being one of the richest people in the world (the Western middle class and higher) isn't necessarily the most fulfilling existence that there is. Comfortable, perhaps, but not necessarily more than that.
- iamcurious 12y agoIt takes a lot of deliberate mental practice to learn not to care about what others have or what they might think of you, and few people bother. Yes. We teach children to brush their teeth to avoid cavities. Maybe we should also teach them to brush their minds to avoid anxiety.
- Dewie3 12y ago> Maybe we should also teach them to brush their minds to avoid anxiety. Isn't it children that should be teaching us about that? :)
- dasil003 12y agoSo many confounding factors. Culture and social pressures pay a large part in how happy adults will claim to be.
- rgbrenner 12y agoHowever, the material deprivation seems to catch up eventually. If you compare the relative rankings of children’s reported happiness with their grown-up counterparts (pdf), the results change significantly. Woah... what a leap. You really couldn't think of anything else that might affect an adults happiness other than materialism? Edit: Just checked the PDF.. it's the World Happiness Report. It does not say what the article says.
- Zancarius 12y agoI agree. I think this is one of those "correlation doesn't necessarily equal causation" articles. I'm sure some of it has to do with material items, but I can't help after reading some of the comments here (markyc's comment on Romania, for instance) that there are far more things at play: Cultural values, adulthood stresses, etc. Not every culture places a strong emphasis on material goods, and not every culture that is strongly materialistic is made happy by material assets. Out of curiosity, I had a look at some of the metrics on Wikipedia for comparison. Colombia ranks 4th according to the adult "happiness index" (after Germany) but 80th on the inequality-adjusted human development index and 98th on the standard HDI--compared to Norway which ranks 1st in both metrics. I can't say I know what this means, but from what I understand, I'd imagine that countries higher on the HDI index therefore have more equal access to services adults find important (like healthcare) and more equal income (and therefore purchasing power) and "should" be happier. Likewise, these countries ought to have greater access to material goods. (But, there's also the issue of who they interviewed, their income levels, etc.) I could be completely wrong, but I just can't imagine that owning a plethora of things necessarily equates to increased happiness.
- jandrewrogers 12y agoNotice that this changes right around the age of puberty. Having grown up quite poor, my hypothesis is straightforward. Before you are a teenager, the things that make you happy and that you value are largely disconnected from money. Happiness is more about the environment not being pathological more than it is about having material goods. Children invent their own happiness. As a teenager, it becomes about the mating ritual. In that context, relative material deprivation can have a significant adverse impact on the ability to attract a quality mate. I would expect that in countries where it is relatively easy to change your material position in society would have happier adults than one where there was less opportunity because it gives the person more ability to improve their outcomes on the mate selection front.
- alexashka 12y agoI think you're coming from a place of a young adult. Anybody with kids will see it quite differently - there's a lot more to it than mate selection :) As for kids being happy - they just have near infinite energy to spare. As your responsibilities increase and your infinite energy begins to whither, it's a different dynamic.
- barry-cotter 12y agoCould you expand on your point? I'm a kindergarten teacher and I'm currently doing a developmental psychology course. While there is a lot more to it than mate selection that is very, very important. Erikson said the main task or crisis of the adolescent phase is identity versus identity confusion but developing one's own identity is a necessity for all facets of adult life, mate selection included. The hollowness of most adolescent experience; Go to school, learn what we tell you to, do as you're told, the general high school experience means that socialising is where most adolescent's mental energy goes. Since this is a zero sum game and a very large part of it is mate acquisition I don't see that there's that much more to it than mate acquisition.
- sukilot 12y agoSocializing a absolutely not zero sum. Only a narrow form of pair bonding is.
- Dewie3 12y agoI've long wondered about whether adults really aren't wiser than children. Smarter, yes, but the wisdom might be largely a blob of limiting and pessimistic beliefs. And a very fragmented wisdom: adults argue and wage wars over the right ways to live. And if we aren't condemning others for their lifestyles and views on life, it might be because we are too busy trying to find our own purpose and path. Does it really take a lifetime to gain wisdom about life? Or is it adults that unlearn the wisdom of childhood, and forever after that struggle to find wisdom in an adult paradigm which is fundamentally flawed?
- alexashka 12y agoSounds like you're asking abstract questions instead of concrete ones. The concrete questions will have concrete answers and you can go from there. With abstract questions, you can sit around wondering for eternity. Unless you come to recognize that you're not getting anywhere (life will remind you soon enough) and do something concrete instead :) If you replace wisdom with 'competence' it becomes much more down to earth. When somebody else is feeding, clothing, scheduling, teaching etc and all you have to do is use your base instincts, it's easy to be competent, you don't need to do anything. When you have to feed, clothe, schedule, teach etc yourself AND others AND then some, it can be quite a challenge. Children are not competent at much of anything, so there you go :)
- Dewie3 12y agoAbstract questions are great when you don't quite know what to hone in on, so that you don't get prematurely bogged down in specifics. Specifics which might be superflouous to your question, or maybe even misleading. They are also great when you want to have a general conversation with a general crowd, where more broad and general questions and topics can facilitate more discussion with several people, whereas more concrete, opinionated and assumptious questions would only attract a few others if anyone. As for myself, my own suspicions and enquires are a bit more focused and opinionated than you might get the impression of here. As for asking more concrete questions in this place, I see little point. At least as far as your benefit is concerned since you know everything on this topic already.
- 12y ago
- robhack 12y agoWell I can definitely count as being happy as a children, and quite often depressed as an adult. But material deprivation doesn't explain that, at all. As a child/teenager I could be happy just playing around (outside/legos/video games). Now I'm just like "what's the point?" or generally getting bored really fast about pretty much anything and just wondering about the meaninglessness of life.
- alexashka 12y agoIt's a transitional phase :) If you can find some people to do stuff with that you like, it's quite fun. A lot more fun frankly - as a child, you can only do so much. As an adult with a career in IT, you can do a looooot more. Plus you get to have sex, aw ye! If you're bored, you haven't found the right people and it likely means you have trouble getting along with them to begin with, so work on that.
- robhack 12y agoThanks, you might be right. I don't have trouble getting along though, I have trouble approaching and connecting. I can work on the approaching, but the connecting is problematic because of the whole getting bored of anything stuff. Hard to make any meaningful relationships when you don't give a ;;; about pretty much anything.
- contingencies 12y agoTry travel, especially weirder types like long distance cycle-touring or sailing. This way you get new society, new people, new environment, and exercise and a sense of adventure to boot... and these often appeal to nerdier types because of the system / self-reliance element and the freedom to escape annoying environments.
- alexashka 12y agoApproaching what? Oh these pick-up ideas that poison the minds of the young and impressionable! You can't work on the approaching because that's not the root of the problem. It's like this - some people form groups based on chit chat and hanging together. It usually involves alcohol and hooking up, that's kinda the point of it all. And what keeps it going is the never-ending gossip surrounding who did what with whom. That's late highshcool, college/uni and a few years afterwards for some folks. People who are more intellectually inclined tend to not be a part of those groups because they're 'boring' - which's another way of saying you can't relate to them and they can't relate to you. You're not 'connecting'. Here's the crucial element - smart people relate based on doing things that take skill, average folks relate based on liking same music, same clothes, etc. Once you're good at something average people want to be good at - they'll put up with your inability to relate to them based on 'boring' things. You'll be this 'Steve Jobs'-like weird-o they'll come to appreciate. In turn, when they like you, you'll get to have sex with them and stuff like that, and YOU will learn that the stuff you couldn't relate to them about, is not so bad after all. It just wasn't intuitive for you. Once you're good at making women (or men if you're a woman) happy, you all of a sudden have this superpower that everybody wants. So it's this self perpetuating cycle but you gotta get good at something that is going to give you social points, so that you can catch up on what being 'cool' is all about. Some of those things are being in a good band, dancing, comedy, sports etc. Nobody cares that you know how to install Linux, but if you can get up and sing at Karaoke night and get a standing ovation, all of a sudden you're a little rockstar.
- randyrand 12y agoI wonder how children emotions were in the early 1800s, then. I wonder how it affects things.
- thatcat 12y agoSince the last part of the brain to mature is the prefrontal cortex which involves planning; perhaps adolescents simply can't imagine long enough into the future to under stand why they might want so much money and stuff, whereas an adult would be considering retirement and worrying about longterm stability.
- markyc 12y agoAlmost half of Romania is still rural, so growing up is awesome (farms, animals, free range everything) Adults don't have it that easy in the country side
- rokhayakebe 12y agoRandom thoughts on the subject "Happiness" and "Confidence" are two of the most dangerous words in American Culture. I really wonder who benefits from this. On Culture Until the age of 19, I was in Western Africa. In our language there is no direct substitute for the question "Are you happy?" I can ask "are you sick, hungry, lost, fast, slow, smart, bad, good, angry,etc..," but I have no easy straight way of asking "Are you happy?" That is not to say people are happy, that is just to say the words/questions shape the culture. On Material Deprivation On the other hand I noticed the difference between my status and my friends. I had friends I would not bring to my home as a kid; these kids would spend on clothes what was our family's monthly income. Material deprivation is entirely subjective nevertheless. I also had cousins, family friends, who found our home the best place to be during their holidays. They would usually live in more remotes part of the country or in the suburbs, not the main city. On Material Deprivation "Appearance starts where performance ends." I notice the times one finds hope or purpose bigger than themselves (even if temporarily) they do not care so much about appearance. Take the average startup entrepreneur. They could live in a shack and be content if they were confident they had the next Facebook in hand. On the other hand they could land a job at Google for $250k yearly and be miserable because their goal was to build a unicorn. To this end whenever I worry about appearances, I know internally something is lacking. Something deeper. It happens on and off, I realize it. "Ignorance is really bliss" I have noticed something: philosophers and analytical minds seem unhappy, religious minds seem just accepting, and those who "do not appear" very intelligent are having a freaking good time in life.
- Dewie3 12y ago> I have noticed something: philosophers and analytical minds seem unhappy, religious minds seem just accepting, and those who "do not appear" very intelligent are having a freaking good time in life. Which begs the question: who really are the smart ones? :-) Smarter people might have a tendency, more than others, to brood and worry over existential questions and matters that happen to be depressing. But worrying about things that are out of their small hands isn't exactly productive, or smart.
- rokhayakebe 12y ago
- known 12y agoIt sounds like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_mobility http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_mobility versus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_mobility http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_mobility