2 ms·
If you're intending to show how the previous argument is fallacious by constructing an obviously silly equivalent but substituting x for 'consciousness' then I
by andybak 12y ago
If you're intending to show how the previous argument is fallacious by constructing an obviously silly equivalent but substituting x for 'consciousness' then I don't think you've achieved what you think you've achieved.
'Love' or 'justice' or any other x that would work in this context depend themselves on consciousness and therefore the only silly part of the resulting argument is that "x is the universe itself" only works if x is the broadest aspect of the concept under discussion - i.e. consciousness itself.
I'm not saying the argument isn't flawed. It's possibly a hand-waving, question-begging, non-explanation. But it's a natural place to reach if, like me, you think a Descartian "I have qualia therefore I am" can't be hand-waved away as easily as some claim.