4 ms·
The peer-review before an article is published is just a sanity check, like Fizz-Buzz during an interview. The more valuable check is what happens after a pape
by saalweachter 12y ago
The peer-review before an article is published is just a sanity check, like Fizz-Buzz during an interview.
The more valuable check is what happens after a paper is published, when your peers read the article and discuss it and critique it and try to replicate it and publish responses to it. What makes peer-reviewed journals valuable to science is the that lots of practitioners read it; the value of peer-review is that it makes the journals more interesting for practitioners to read because it doesn't waste their time on obvious crap.
Publishing a paper is not a stamp of truthiness. It's a communication to the community that something is interesting. Maybe it's right, maybe it's wrong, time will tell. Truth emerges from a large body of research and publications from a large number of researchers. Any of the individual papers along the way may be missteps; it is only in hindsight that a particular paper can be picked out as seminal or definitive.
That's OK.
- Retric 12y agoIt's also a stamp of relevance. Like the front page of HN vs new.