3 ms·
This dataset appears to be the same one used for the "where you grow up affects how much money you make" article and seems to directly speak to what a few comme
by majormajor 12y ago
This dataset appears to be the same one used for the "where you grow up affects how much money you make" article and seems to directly speak to what a few commenters here noticed about that one: it was looking at household income, so less likely to marry -> more likely to be two datapoints making less money in two separate households than one datapoint making a higher combined total.
This is even noted in the other article: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/05/03/upshot/the-best-and-worst-places-to-grow-up-how-your-area-compares.html?abt=0002&abg=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/05/03/upshot/the-bes...
"Here, better or worse is measured by the household incomes of children in early adulthood. This makes New York look worse than it would if individual incomes were used, because it, along with Northern California, has some of the lowest marriage rates in the country. Manhattan is actually better than most of the country at raising the individual incomes of poor girls. Marriage rates, too, are strongly affected by where children grow up."
But that seems to essentially invalidate broad swaths of the original article, instead of merely being mentioned in the last paragraph in regard to just two areas...
There are still probably some interesting outliers, but it looks like they're not the ones discussed in the original. For instance, I noticed that LA county, one of the listed lower-income-causing ones in the original article, is indeed 4 percentage points less likely to marry. But then I saw that it's neighbor, Ventura County, is both 3 percentage points less likely to marry by 26 and has households making 7 percent more at age 26. That's potentially interesting. Doubtless there are others that are more likely to marry and also lower income...