4 ms·
I agree with astrodust, and would like to point out to the GP that arranging the real estate necessary, plus getting all the zoning/easements/whatever (I'm not
by mindcrime 12y ago
I agree with astrodust, and would like to point out to the GP that arranging the real estate necessary, plus getting all the zoning/easements/whatever (I'm not in property development), would easily be prohibitively expensive for a company trying to join any two major cities.
I never said it would be easy.
- mozumder 12y agoOf course it would be easy. Private companies can easily take people's property - just point a gun at them. It worked well for the East India company. If we can eliminate government, we can eliminate the people's protection racket. This will allow private companies to flourish, and the weak to be eliminated.
- mindcrime 12y agoThe East India Company was a "private company" in the loosest possible sense. It was operating with the explicit sanction of the British Empire and was effectively a government in its own right. I find it amusing that you would cite that example as an argument FOR government, as I think it stands as a classic example of the worst of what government enables.
- mozumder 12y agoYah, I don't get why you feel the East India company was any different from any other company?
- mindcrime 12y agoWhich other private companies have been given the authority to more or less declare war and occupy territory as they see fit? I guess you could argue Halliburton comes close, but the point is that most private companies aren't given those powers.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The East India Company was a "private company" in the loosest possible sense. It was operating with the explicit sanction of the British Empire and was effectively a government in its own right. Every company that exists as separate juridical entity (e.g., every corporation, for starters) does so with the explicit sanction of a government and is an exercise of government power. The East India Company was a private company in exactly the same sense as any other "private" corporation.
- mindcrime 12y agoThe East India Company was a private company in exactly the same sense as any other "private" corporation. That's just being pedantic. It was a "private company" yes, but a private company that was granted powers far beyond those given to pretty much any other private company. They were allowed to maintain their own private army and effectively rule large parts of India as though they were the government. That's a HUGE difference from the typical private company.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoNot to mention they had a government-granted monopoly on trade with India for the first century of their existence.
- mozumder 12y agoNot sure what you're getting at here.. are you saying, that, without government, the East India company wouldn't be stealing people's lands? It seems like you didn't think your cunning plan all the way through, because you seem to be implying that you need more government regulation on what private corporations can do, correct? Or are you saying that, without government regulation, the East India company wouldn't have formed their own private army? Do you think private armed militias, that are legal today in the US, be allowed to exist? You're going to have to reconcile your position of "less government" with "leads to more private armies".
- mindcrime 12y ago