3 ms·
> 2) IMO a much more stringent form of peer review is necessary. That disregards the cost of review. Reviewing and repeating experiments uses resources that co
by munificent 12y ago
> 2) IMO a much more stringent form of peer review is necessary.
That disregards the cost of review. Reviewing and repeating experiments uses resources that could be spent elsewhere. On the long tail of papers that are not high impact even if correct, that's probably not a good allocation of effort.
What I think would be better is that as a paper crawls up the impact curve (probably measured by citations), then additional resources should be spent validating and repeating it.
In theory, that's how the system already works since everyone wants to build on top of or refute famous papers. In practice, I don't know if it does.
- Retric 12y agoI am not suggesting people need to necessarily spend more time doing the review, just accept less BS. In many cases the bar is far to low.
- bjelkeman-again 12y agoRepeating experiments is not a wasted effort. "More than half of biomedical findings cannot be reproduced – we urgently need a way to ensure that discoveries are properly checked" - Elizabeth Iorns is co-founder and CEO of Science Exchange. Science which can't be repeated, that is problematic. [1] http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21528826.000-is-medical-science-built-on-shaky-foundations.html http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21528826.000-is-medica...