4 ms·
It looks like it's an introduction to by-hand proofs about software, rather than to software-assisted proofs. That's a shame—I got very excited at the thought
by JadeNB 12y ago
It looks like it's an introduction to by-hand proofs about software, rather than to software-assisted proofs. That's a shame—I got very excited at the thought of a 'Little X' take on proof assistants!
- JadeNB 12y agoSometimes I can understand downvotes in retrospect, but that one puzzles me. I thought that it was a constructive contribution for others who had the same expectation that I did. Was it actually not? Should I just not have said anything, or should I have phrased it differently?
- nmrm2 12y agoWasn't me, but you might've been downvoted because the book description states: The book comes with a simple proof assistant to help readers work through the book and complete solutions to every example. So, there is a proof assistant.
- JadeNB 12y agoThanks for this helpful clarification; I hadn't noticed that in the description. (I do note, feebly, that there's a difference between learning to use a one-off proof assistant, and learning to use a 'popular' one.)
- WaxProlix 12y agoMy girlfriend and I are starting to play around with proof assistants (avoiding the coq joke as best I can...) and it would be great to have something like this to go along with that endeavour.
- pykello 12y agoWhich proof assistants did you play with? Why are avoiding coq?
- JadeNB 12y agoI think WaxProlix (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9553471 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9553471) was avoiding puerile jokes about (a homonym for) Coq, not avoiding Coq itself.
- WaxProlix 12y agoYes, exactly, especially in the context of "my girlfriend and I", "playing with", etc. Low-(brow|hanging fruit), even for me.
- tel 12y agoI liked Coq d'Art