3 ms·
the american train system is particularly cronyist. It's an issue very well addressed in the (not libertarian) book "Free Lunch: How the Wealthiest Americans E
by dnautics 12y ago
the american train system is particularly cronyist. It's an issue very well addressed in the (not libertarian) book "Free Lunch: How the Wealthiest Americans Enrich Themselves at Government Expense". Especially damning is how amtrak leases their right of way from freight carriers, who a) give freight trains the right of way - leading to frequent delays and b) lobby the NTSB to keep safety standards low.
The american train disaster is not a failure due to selfishness - it is a failure due to central planning in the worst fashion: corruption.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> lobby the NTSB to keep safety standards low This. The NTSB has been trying to get safety systems that automatically enforce speed limits (which would've prevented the recent fatal crash) in place since 1970 (http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/2015/05/more-proof-of-americas-inadequate-infrastructure/ http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/2015/05/more-proof-of-americas-...). The freight operators have successfully lobbied Congress to push it off to (thus far) 2020.
- gaadd33 12y agoWait, what right of way does Amtrak lease from freight carriers? They outright own the Northeast Corridor and tracks as far west as Harrisburg, PA. I think they lease some bits of track from various state department of transportation and they obviously have trackage rights with the various freight carriers. The NTSB seems to have higher standards for railroads than elsewhere in the world, that's one reason why we can't just import high speed trainsets, pretty much every other passenger rail car is much lighter and less sturdy than ours. I think much of that is due to our rail system handling both freight and passenger traffic.
- osi 12y agoYes, the NTSB requires any passenger rail car that is on a train network that is somehow connected to rail that carries freight to be built to standards for collisions with freight traffic. This is ridiculous, because it means we can't import those high speed trainsets, even in the northeast corridor, where the tracks are Amtrak-owned, and do not see freight traffic, just because the rails do link to the freight network.
- AnimalMuppet 12y ago> Wait, what right of way does Amtrak lease from freight carriers? Well, everywhere west of Harrisburg and south of DC, Amtrak runs on the right of way of freight railroads. That isn't "lease" exactly, but Amtrak pays to use those tracks, which is essentially the same thing.
- gaadd33 12y agoRight, that's called trackage rights and are given priority time slots over freight trains. However when the slot is missed then the trains are treated as any other freight.