4 ms·
Is there a meaningful and substantial difference between those two things? Both amount to "your input is not welcome here", both amount to classifying one's ide
by Karunamon 12y ago
Is there a meaningful and substantial difference between those two things? Both amount to "your input is not welcome here", both amount to classifying one's identity more important than the content of their speech, and the entire concept of a "safe space" is one in which mere disagreement is explicitly disallowed.
- untog 12y agoAbsolutely there is a difference. If a group of women are talking about their experiences of sexism in the workplace they ought to be able to do without a man coming in and "actually"-ing them.
- Karunamon 12y agoThis set of questions is going to sound a lot more flippant than the tone it's intended to be in, but I am curious as to the answers: Why is that? Why is someone's identity more important than the content of their speech in this particular case? Is it impossible for anyone/a man to be against sexism and yet disagree with someone's characterization of an event? Are all ideas sacred and above criticism now, or only some ideas? Which ones? Who gets to decide that? Why them? Why does the right of people to be free from criticism take priority over the right of people to have a discussion? Why does mere disagreement necessarily need to be classed as a negative thing (as you just did?) How can such an environment foster any kind of healthy discussion, as opposed to me-too echo-chambering?
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoAttempt at an honest answer: If a group has been marginalized, belittled, and excluded for long enough, it can damage the people in that group. They can need a safe place to heal, to realize that they matter, that they are as worthwhile as anyone else, and that they don't have to be what their oppressors said they were. A safe place can be very important in that process. Or a safe place can be a place where a bunch that feels oppressed because somebody looked at them funny, and feels more oppressed because nobody else thinks they're oppressed, can get together and rehash their sense of victimhood and exclude anyone who disagrees. Human nature being what it is, the second is perhaps more likely than the first. But that does not make the first invalid (when genuinely needed).
- jklinger410 12y agoSo you advocate judging the validity of a person's points not by their content, but by their sex and race? Classic illiberal progressivism.