4 ms·
The flip side is that many proposals such as Basic Income proposals unconditionally rewarding people with above world-average wages simply for being Swiss citiz
by notahacker 12y ago
The flip side is that many proposals such as Basic Income proposals unconditionally rewarding people with above world-average wages simply for being Swiss citizens, or offers of free, permanent and decent housing for people who find themselves homeless in the right municipality, seem to increase the likelihood of position in life being a consequence of fortune rather than effort to take advantage of it...
There might be a lot of luck in being born rich, and usually a lot of misfortune in being homeless, but there's also a lot of work and effort that goes into being just about solvent but not able to afford granite worktops, and its actually often people in those positions that are most inclined to gripe at perceived profligacy. Whilst few of them would be keen to have to deal with the difficulties of the average [ex]homeless person, particularly for something as trivial as granite worktops, it's also a little hard to blithely dismiss them as overly privileged.
- notahacker 12y agoNot sure what's attracting the drive-by downvotes here? I know BI is popular here, but is there anything actually wrong about my observation that it targets people lucky enough to be born in a particular country rather than unlucky enough to have fallen upon financial hardship? Or that people who think granite worktops are a luxury probably aren't emblematic of the selfish rich?
- PopeOfNope 12y agoYou committed badthink, so you get downvoted. Try not to take in personally. It's just what happens here these days. As for what you said, I don't think it's useful it put everything in camps of "lucky" and "unlucky." It assumes that there's nothing an individual can do himself to improve or worsen his station. In the USA and Canada, of all places, that's manifestly untrue. While rags to riches stories are rare, poor to upper middle class stories are extremely common, especially in tech.