3 ms·
> However, it absolutely made sense to provide government assistance to GM, even though GM was run incorrectly, because of the broader reaching effects of letti
by anamax 17y ago
> However, it absolutely made sense to provide government assistance to GM, even though GM was run incorrectly, because of the broader reaching effects of letting it fall at that time.
That's true only if something is being done so the effects of it failing will be lower or if the failure is averted and the cost of the assistance was less than the benefit received.
However it's likely that GM is going to fail anyway and at roughly the same cost. Was delaying that really worth $12B?
> Now, we ask should the financial industry be regulated, and we see the answer is different, because the case is different; our entire dollar based economy is intertwined with the liquidity of the financial markets, so a worst case scenario there can trigger a severe economic depression, as we almost experienced.
You're assuming that regulation works. Since regulation arguably created the problems that we just experienced (Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are creations of regulation as was the dependence of financial institutions on them, which caused said financial institutions to fail when Fannie/Freddie went down), that's questionable at best.
- jeromec 17y ago> Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are creations of regulation as was the dependence of financial institutions on them, which caused said financial institutions to fail when Fannie/Freddie went down Huh? Am I missing something? Regulation is a rule (or law). Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are government sponsored enterprises (GSEs). That would be like saying the Small Business Administration is business regulation. Also, to my knowledge Fannie and Freddie did not fail. I think we would have noticed considering they cover trillions of dollars worth of mortgages.
- anamax 17y ago> Regulation is a rule (or law). Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are government sponsored enterprises (GSEs). Fannie and Freddie are creations of law in the form of GSEs. Their GSE status made them especially vulnerable to govt interference. They weren't independent of govt in any meaningful sense. > That would be like saying the Small Business Administration is business regulation. It would be if SBA controlled as large a segment of biz lending as Fannie and Freddie did of the mortgage market. Fannie and Freddie define "conforming mortgage". Their lending standards define what mortages are sellable. If they screw it up, as they did, the market takes a huge hit. > Also, to my knowledge Fannie and Freddie did not fail. They got billions of dollars pumped into them and their stock price collapsed. They're not essentially in receivership and are running on govt funds. That's failure. > I think we would have noticed considering they cover trillions of dollars worth of mortgages. What's to notice? The failure of an institution doesn't imply that the debts owed it go away, so folks are still paying their mortgages (or not), regardless of Fannie and Freddie's problems. The take-over is designed to keep mortgages flowing. For a while it wasn't working - if you were looking for a mortgage, you noticed.