3 ms·
In the same way that one shouldn't tar the 'skeptics' with the same brush used for Big Oil, one should be cautious about 'recurring themes' based on excerpts. T
by nkurz 17y ago
In the same way that one shouldn't tar the 'skeptics' with the same brush used for Big Oil, one should be cautious about 'recurring themes' based on excerpts. There are some messages where the real scientists distinguish themselves nicely from the scoundrels. Take this one for example: http://www.anelegantchaos.org/cru/emails.php?eid=1010&filename=1252154659.txt http://www.anelegantchaos.org/cru/emails.php?eid=1010&fi...
I'm sure it's not perfect, but it looks like a good example of scientific progress being made:
Nonetheless, it's unfortunate that I flipped
the Korttajarvi data. We used the density data as the
temperature proxy, as recommended to me by Antii Ojala
(co-author of the original work). It's weakly inversely
related to organic matter content. I should have
used the inverse of density as the temperature proxy. I
probably got confused by the fact that the 20th century
shows very high density values and I inadvertently
equated that directly with temperature.
This is new territory for me, but not acknowledging an
error might come back to bite us. I suggest that we nip
it in the bud and write a brief update showing the
corrected composite(Nick's graph) and post it to
RealClimate. Do you all agree?
Be cautious on generalizing across all the emails as a single corpus. Throw the book at the scoundrels, but don't lose sight of the good science being done in the background. This message would make me tend to trust what Darrell Kaufmann has to say in the future.