6 ms·
How I found glaring errors in Einstein's calculations (2009)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoThat's not actually hard to do. I would be completely unsurprised were I to learn that Einstein would be unable to get consistent answers were he to repeatedly count on his own toes. There is a great deal of difference between symbolic mathematics - calculus and the like - and arithmetic. While not as bad as Einstein, I'm very poor at arithmetic as well.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dalke 12y agoThe article characterizes crackpots who claim there are serious problems with the underpinnings of science that can be rectified with college level or even high-school level math. It doesn't actually find a calculation flaw in Einstein's work.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI wasn't criticizing Einstein's theories, I was criticizing Einstein's arithmetic. In a letter to Mt. Wilson observatory, he requested that they point their telescope just off the edge of the sun in full daylight - NOT during an eclipse - to determine whether the stars whose light passed through the sun's gravity would be out of place with respect to the positions of those stars when the sun was not nearby. He was apparently unaware that to point an observatory scope that close to the sun - I don't recall whether it was the 100" or the 60" - would melt the glass photographic plate. His calculations of where the stars would be, was wildly inaccurate. Someone - a Mt. Wilson astronomer I expect but don't really know - had to point out to Einstein that he required an eclipse. I expect someone else had to do the arithmetic for the African eclipse expedition. In my original post I clearly distinguished symbolic mathematics from arithmetic. I've studied some tensor calculus, while straightforward in principle it is conceptually quite difficult to follow. Einstein had his tensors right what he did not have correct was "2 + 2". I mean like he'd try that computation then come up with "5".
- dalke 12y agoBut what does that have to do with the linked-to article?
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI haven't read the article. What I've been repeatedly pointing out is that Einstein was appallingly poor at arithmetic. I am also repeatedly pointing out that his theories are flawless, as far as we can tell through experiment. When Einstein attempted to predict the experimental results of his theory, while the theory was correct, his predictions were wildly inaccurate, because he was really, really bad at arithmetic. I'm not just making this up - I learned it in physics class at Caltech, from the president of the Institute. Caltech is in pasadena, Mt. Wilson overlooks pasadena, the Mt. Wilson Observatory office is in pasadena. Mt. Wilson and Caltech are different organizations but work very closely together.
- dalke 12y agoGrr! Then at least start your first comment with "I haven't read the article, but based on keyword matching in the title I want to say .." or something like that. There's no reason to repeatedly point out that Einstein's theories are flawless. The article specifically says "To most physicists, such discussions are largely irrelevant, as these classic experiments were only the first ones in a long series of tests that showed the complete agreement between observations and predictions from special relativity." See also http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1632 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1632 .
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoHave you considered the possibility that your instructor is not infallible and may have been in error.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoHe was the president of the institute, and a tenured physics professor.
- maaaats 12y agoPlease read the article, not just comment on the headline.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI've studied special relativity through graduate school at UCSC. While I haven't exactly studied general relativity in a formal way I've attended quite a few talks on it by cosmologists and the like. I was an astronomy major at Caltech, but switched to Physics when I realized I prefer to build telescopes rather than look through them. Astronomers don't build telescopes; Opticians do that. However Physicists commonly build their own experimental apparatus.
- seanhandley 12y agoNot sure how I'd feel if my optician prescribed me a telescope.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoopticians make telescopes. Optometrists write prescriptions for eyeglasses. Optometric opticians make eyeglass lenses. Opthalmologists diagnose and treat disease of the eyes. An optometrist can perform an opthalmological exam but cannot prescribe medicine nor practice eyeball surgery.
- seanhandley 12y agoI'd better tell my optician to change the sign outside the shop then...
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoPardon me while I drop by the chemist's shop to pick up some fuming nitric acid, sulfuric acid and glycerin.
- seanhandley 12y agoGoogle Define: optician ɒpˈtɪʃ(ə)n/Submit nounBRITISH a person qualified to prescribe and dispense glasses and contact lenses, and to detect eye diseases ( ophthalmic optician ) or to make and supply glasses and contact lenses ( dispensing optician ). US a dispensing optician.
- EliRivers 12y agoEinstein excelled at mathematics throughout his schooling. There's no evidence that he was a dunce with arithmetic. http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2011/12/albert-einstein-did-not-fail-at-mathematics-in-school/ http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2011/12/albert-einst...
- zamalek 12y ago+1 Einstein was, in fact, so good at math that at 15 he passed that portion of a university entrance examination (although he failed every other subject). A very real example of a super-intelligent human, which normal people regard as "learning disabilities" due to their own inability to comprehend or cope that intelligence - as has been demonstrated in the comments section of this post.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoMy best subject in Physics was electricity and magnetism, which depends heavily on special relativity. I aced the junior year E&M final without ever having shown up to class nor attempted any of the problem sets. I don't recall sitting for a midterm exam, maybe I spaced it. I also successfully petitioned for credit for UCSC's optics class. In my written narrative evaluation, Dr. Scherr said that while I got the correct answers, my derivations were quite different from those of the other students.
- zamalek 12y agoAll of which have nothing to do with Einstein.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoMy point being that I know quite a lot about relativity. Not just that I know about it but have quite a deep understanding of it. I know quite a lot about Einstein as a person.
- seanhandley 12y agoPublished on Wednesday, 01 April 2009 08:17
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoYour comment appeared, disappeared then reappeared. It seems to be here to stay now. Perhaps this is some bug in HN's CMS.
- seanhandley 12y agoMore likely a caching bug, I'd say.
- mhuffman 12y agoSchrödinger's comment!
- kokey 12y agoThat's the guy who invented distributed NoSQL databases?
- maaaats 12y agoI used to discuss these kind of theories online. Or, rather, these kind of people would visit the forums/boards I used to visit, and then present their "great ground shaking theories". As the author here states, most of these theories had fundamental flaws. New particles named after themselves that didn't explain anything the model of physics does today. Or the theories weren't consistent with observations, for instance they failed to explain how pushing one object of 1kg into another object would end up. Most of these people were old, many engineers (edit: which the article agrees with) with a former basic knowledge of physics. They kinda reminds me of the old professor in the movie "Proof", that has lost grip on reality and invented his own "proofs". Or the movie "A beautiful mind" when he's on his worst. It's a bit sad, really.
- bitJericho 12y agoI tried to argue with a crackpot once and even recommended psychiatric help if needed and all it did was make me feel terrible, it did not convince the crackpot. Needless to say I've now resigned to just ignoring them altogether.
- vixen99 12y agoNice segue from 'a crackpot' to 'them'. They have labels pasted all over them so no difficulty in crossing to the other side of the street.
- bitJericho 12y agoWell crackpots are different from me, in that I don't believe I'm one, so yes there is indeed a difference between myself and "them". Sorry if I'm not politically correct enough for you. Just to clarify, I have no issue with crackpots, mentally ill people, whatever you want to call them. My only point is that trying to convince someone that they are a crackpot is not going to work, at least over the internet!
- JadeNB 12y agoI think the claim is not so much that you are or might be a crackpot, as that it's too easy to misdiagnose a genuine revolutionary as a crackpot. The canonical example for mathematicians is Ramanujan (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan); https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan); Hardy would have been perfectly justified in thinking him a crackpot and throwing away his letters, and one of the most valuable collaborations in number theory would never have happened.
- smegel 12y agoI also find this "crackpot" quite entertaining: http://www.sjcrothers.plasmaresources.com/PhD.html http://www.sjcrothers.plasmaresources.com/PhD.html
- madez 12y agoIt saddens me that one who seems to have technical talent in science can fail so miserably at social interaction, with probably fatal consequences for his scientific career. At the same time the behaviour of the professors gives me hope. Several kindly and patiently tried to help him despite him being rude, offending and egocentric. Finding his behaviour positively entertaining is sadistic, and I'd find it contemptible and disgusting. I agree that what crackpots are missing is not scientific method or technical talent but social integration and interaction. An early, informal and honest "this idea is non-sense" can help a lot.
- kokey 12y agoThis is fascinating and I think I can understand why he finds it so interesting, and useful, to study people who disagree with probably the most testable, established, unquestionable parts of science. I hope it will help identify bias and groupthink in less testable, established science.
- mkagenius 12y agoreally Offtopic: but does time really slow down or just the clock we use are dumb? I never believed it.
- augustl 12y agoTime really slows down. GPS satelites wouldn't have worked if it wasn't taken into account. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_analysis_for_the_Global_Positioning_System#Calculation_of_time_dilation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_analysis_for_the_Global_P...
- mkagenius 12y agoThat is again just the clock going haywire.
- soneil 12y agoIt's the clocks on all 24 GPS satellites, all 24 Glonass satellites, and the 8 (so far) Galileo satellites, all going "haywire" by precisely the amount predicted by a theory developed before the first satellite went into space. And it's not a paltry amount - if we didn't understand and plan for this amount, the GPS system would have an error drift of 10km (~6 miles) per day
- augustl 12y agoNo, it's an attribute of time itself, not mechanical clock issues. I _highly_ recommend the book "About Time" http://www.amazon.com/About-Time-Einsteins-Unfinished-Revolution/dp/0684818221 http://www.amazon.com/About-Time-Einsteins-Unfinished-Revolu...
- nicobn 12y agoPlease define "dumb" in the context of a system solely guided by one of the most basic, non-emergent process conceivable (caesium oscillator) ?
- mkagenius 12y ago
- bitwize 12y agoMy favorite is Louis Savain, who would go full mad scientist when his theories were challenged and even laugh like Mandark in his correspondence. Example: http://users.telenet.be/vdmoortel/dirk/Physics/Fumbles/Insanity.html http://users.telenet.be/vdmoortel/dirk/Physics/Fumbles/Insan...
- iorrus 12y agoI am interested in alternative explanations even including nonrelativistic ones... as the current ones we have are largely unsatisfactory so I guess this makes me a 'crackpot'. This is how science is done not blindly answering 'easy questions' (which is what I do in my real life academic job, well not easy..). Personally I just disregard the whole article it is written by someone who is neither a physicist nor engineer, in fact someone without any background in the physical sciences at all. What intellectual right this social scientist has to pontificate on matters he knows nothing about is unknown to me. He seems to disregard the opinion of those who are trained engineers with a PhD as damaged goods or delusional. What right has he to say this with absoloutely no knowledge in the field? Maybe after 8 years of daily academic grind he can come back and write something with a bit more humility. For instance "without actually studying maths and physics - which would show the crackpot why he’s misguided." - How does he know this?? Although my academic background is in EE I have reviewed the physics curriculum at my alma mater and there is little there that I do not already know to an advanced level. Most learnt during my PhD in physics. 'Regular interaction' is important and the textbooks are outdated/immaterial, it's not possible to understand papers unless you are talking to the people involved. This is a man who simply doesn't understand what working in the physical sciences involves. He is totally ignorant of the field. Does he think major advances are happening on a 6 monthly basis?
- opium_tea 12y agoSometimes these crackpots are people of high social status (well, sort of...) http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2006/nov/14/science.comment http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2006/nov/14/science...
- DanBC 12y agoMocton is a hereditary peer. It's worrying that those people have some power, but it could be worse. The previous English minister for energy and climate change (Matthew Hancock) is a climate change denier who refuses to discuss anything related to climate change and who accepts large donations from other prominent climate change deniers. http://rt.com/uk/248605-climate-skeptic-donations-hancock/ http://rt.com/uk/248605-climate-skeptic-donations-hancock/
- nthcolumn 12y agoClickbait title - boring article about amateur scientists.