3 ms·
I think that's the thing about Airbnb. The experience is usually good for the people getting paid, and the people getting the service. It is frequently bad for
by oh_sigh 12y ago
I think that's the thing about Airbnb. The experience is usually good for the people getting paid, and the people getting the service. It is frequently bad for people who are not part of that exchange at all, and just happen to be in close proximity.
The owner of my apartment building has set up an illegal air bnb in an empty apartment(I'm going to guess this is a rent controlled or stabilized apartment "under renovations"). Usually it isn't an issue, besides for frequently seeing groups of strangers come in and out of the building. Last week though, a lovely fellow decided that, after drinking what must be approximately 2 liters of wine, he was going to pick my door to puke outside of(5 floors below his air bnb) at 2AM. He then started crashing into the wall separating my bedroom and the hallway a number of times. Then he went down into the lobby, puked some more right in front of the door, then peed in the stairwell. I think it's pretty straight forward to see why tenants don't want air bnb rentals in their residences.
- hansjorg 12y ago> The experience is usually good for the people getting paid, and the people getting the service. It is frequently bad for people who are not part of that exchange at all, and just happen to be in close proximity. The externalitati.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThat's exactly how the "sharing economy" ended up working in practice. Skirt the law, dump externalities on third parties.
- twic 12y agoPrivatize gains, and socialize losses. A tried and tested formula!
- WalterSear 12y agoIt's also why it's such a darling for the libertarian crowd.
- deciplex 12y agoIn fairness to the "libertarian crowd", the smart ones usually do grok negative externalities, and come up with grandiose (if naive) schemes for internalizing them. The likely result most of the time is a community that spends 20 hours out of every day in various town hall meetings, byzantine tax and fee schedules, an enforcement arm that would have to rival the Stasi in order to actually work, and of course the whole thing is very susceptible to corruption. But they do know what negative externalities are, at least.
- microcolonel 12y agoHow exactly would the libertarian crowd get "byzantine" tax? Avoiding taxation in general seems like one of the major components of the idea.
- cbd1984 12y agoBy calling them "fees" or "voluntary contributions" or similar. Taxes are only bad if a government extracts them at gunpoint. If a non-governmental force extracts them at... well, the gun is still there, I suppose, but hidden behind a layer of "If you don't pay, we sue, and if you don't pay after the lawsuit, the guns come out"... they're morally A-OK.
- deciplex 12y agoI only call it a "tax" as a shorthand, libertarians would not call it that. Rather they devise a system where, for example in the case of air pollution, there is no such thing as a public good, and instead of regulation and fines, potential air polluters would need to enter into a contract with the owners of the air in order to secure the right to pollute the air. And it pretty much goes downhill from there. It's one of those things that might sometimes work okay on paper, but the trouble is that you can't actually try it out in practice due to the difficulty of assembling into a coherent community, a critical mass of people with the correct sort of deranged insanity to want to try it in the first place.
- neuro_imager 12y agoI get your point but (partly to play devil's advocate)... How is this significantly different from traditional businesses? - Good for people getting paid. - Good (maybe) for people getting the service (which is often mediocre at best). - Bad for competitors. - Bad for people who invested in a competing service/product/related industry. - Often bad for the environment, neighbourhood etc.
- SixSigma 12y agoThat's the whole point. Society has constructed mechanisms for dealing with externalities: governments, laws, regulations and taxes.
- xaybey 12y agoSo? What prevents any of the other tenants in your apartment from doing that?
- ild 12y ago1. Dent in rental history or police history. 2. Social repercussions with neighbors
- cbd1984 12y ago> Social repercussions with neighbors ...and? If this amounts to dirty looks in the shared hallway or similar, it's pointless. In fact, it's worse than pointless: The caring, socially-responsible people who don't want to have assholes will be hurt worst, and will be motivated to leave the business after a few bad apples, whereas the people who honestly don't give two shits until the police show up will carry on regardless, and take on more assholes as long as their checks don't bounce. Social approbation only works well in tight-knit societies where someone not liking you can have ripple effects through everything you do. "The Scarlet Letter" is an example, both of how it works and how it is honestly a bad way to run a society. You need laws to put teeth in the "don't do that" parts of the social contract, and you need to enforce those laws. Lawsuits can work, but they're messy and expensive and generally so draining for both sides that winning one is something of an academic point. That's one reason we as a society attempt to use lawsuits as a method of last resort, and create regulations and regulatory bodies which can enforce punishments without sending an injured party through the massive financial and personal ruin of bringing suit against someone.
- agorabinary 12y agoYes, Airbnb's "thing" (dirty little secret) is that some widespread neighbor abuse as documented in an HN anecdote is polluting the social value of a $20B startup. Solution? Instead of allowing building managers/owners to allow/disallow short term leases by their lessees as determined by the externality-including market value of such a policy, let's just ban it altogether. The principle of the least-elegant solution.
- wj 12y agoI would imagine many, if not most, people's leases don't allow them to rent their places out. You see many listings that require discretion regarding entry, particularity as to where to park on the street, and forbid talking with neighbors. NYC might be an exception as it seems like subletting is a big thing there.
- oh_sigh 12y agoAlmost all full-space(that is, not staying in an extra bedroom while the owner is present) air bnb units in NYC are illegal. Subletting is usually legal, unless stated in your lease, but there are laws against short term stays(< 30 days).
- oh_sigh 12y agoNo, the "thing" is common to any short term rental. It just so happens that AirBNB is the most popular way of booking a short term rental. This "thing", is exactly why so many municipalities have explicit laws on the books regulating and taxing hotels.