I may have responded to the wrong person (or you've edited your post) as the post I meant to respond to was most definitely comparing waterfall to agile. It's

I may have responded to the wrong person (or you've edited your post) as the post I meant to respond to was most definitely comparing waterfall to agile. It's very common for agile proponents to push Waterfall as the necessary alternative to agile, but that's a logical fallacy.