5 ms·
>> HGST, Seagate and Western Digital drives all have the serial number of the drive on the top end of the drive. Toshiba drives do not. Is simply printing and
by bluedino 12y ago
>> HGST, Seagate and Western Digital drives all have the serial number of the drive on the top end of the drive. Toshiba drives do not.
Is simply printing and adding a label to each hard drive not enough, is it too error-prone, or what?
- Symbiote 12y agoScrawling the last three digits of the serial number onto the drive end with a permanent marker would probably suffice.
- outworlder 12y agoI'd be surprised if they didn't actually have an automated system to scan and record the serial numbers.
- atYevP 12y agoYev from Backblaze here -> The drive manufacturer won't do it for us (at least not at our scale). We're currently chatting to some channel retailers that would be able to do it for us and allow us to scale a little bit. It was discouraging us from buying in larger quantities, but if the price of the drive + labeling works out, we'll try some larger orders.
- DannyBee 12y agoThe drives don't get delivered in pods for you, right? So why is this not just part of the "take all drives from large box/crate/etc" process for the drives? IE whoever is taking them out of boxes puts them down, one by one, in a simple little labeling machine that slaps label on them (and records into a stupid database the label). If you want something more advanced, labeling machine has small camera that takes picture of top of drive for further identification, you can process and store all the barcoded info that exist in the image (unlike OCR, the barcodes should be 100% accurate)
- atYevP 12y agoWe do not get them delivered in pods no, we put them in at the datacenter. We don't do it because of the time constraints. Lets say it takes 30 seconds to do one individual drive. With 45 drives in a chassis that's 22 minutes per pod, and we get a ton of pods and drives delivered at once. Our datacenter techs are busy enough as it is, so if we can offload them, we try to. Now, if these drives were inexpensive and had a 0% failure rate over 4 years and the manufacturer/retail chain supplier still refused to put them on, yea we'd hire someone to do just labeling and do it ourselves, but for now the math doesn't work out.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoYev, if you're taking a drive out of the anti-static bag and installing it in a machine it takes slightly less than 3 seconds to pull an asset tag bar code off a sheet of printed labels and stick it on the drive. Two scans of the drive asset tag, serial number on the label, and poof you are done. A very large consumer of drives at a previous employer :-) did this pretty efficiently. When we expanded our cluster for Blekko we did this for the 5000 drives we got from Western digital (well the scanning, we didn't really need an asset tag) and it goes really quickly with a code scanner in hand and a python script recording the values.
- atYevP 12y agoSure, maybe my math was off, I'm not a datacenter guy, they are very efficient ;-) It comes down to cost/time. We did small-scale tests and they went pretty well. We're hoping to avoid the manual process on our end, but if we can't get a distributor to label them and it makes financial sense to buy the Toshiba's, we'll do it ourselves :)
- moe 12y agoWe don't do it because of the time constraints. Lets say it takes 30 seconds to do one individual drive. But in your article you claim that the unlabeled Toshiba drives lengthen the maintenance time by "a few minutes" every time they fail. Since all drives eventually fail, wouldn't it make sense to trade those "few minutes" at the end of the lifecycle for a constant 30 seconds at the beginning?
- monochromatic 12y agoSounds like a job for a temp.
- wcchandler 12y agoI was thinking an intern, but yeah... sounds like a great way for somebody low-level to get their foot in the door.
- sunstone 12y agoHi Yev, just want to say that I love these posts that Backblaze does regarding drive reliability. Thanks.
- atYevP 12y agoCool! Well, that's why we write them, people seem to dig them! And we have a lot of stats and data from our experiences to share, so it's mutually beneficial!
- userbinator 12y agoIt wouldn't be hard to determine whether the barcode/number on the end is unique or not - if it isn't, you'd probably find collisions very easily especially within ones of the same batch. I did a bit of searching (there's a noticeable shortage of photos of Toshiba HDD ends on the Internet...) and figure that it's probably some sort of batch code - the 3 I could find and read were POU34250025173, POU34250027527, and POU37250019573. The one in Backblaze's photo is POU34350016620.
- qq66 12y agoWhy change a process that works without a compelling reason?