5 ms·
Why would a short term resident care about the outward appearance of the property? Why, really, would they care that a neighbour thinks their music is too loud?
by untog 12y ago
Why would a short term resident care about the outward appearance of the property? Why, really, would they care that a neighbour thinks their music is too loud? They've moving out in three days anyway.
Close quarters living like we have in major cities is a very delicate dance that involves building a relationship with your neighbours. Introducing someone not committed to that can absolutely cause huge problems.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> Why would a short term resident care about the outward appearance of the property? Why, really, would they care that a neighbour thinks their music is too loud? They've moving out in three days anyway. Because they could be fined or otherwise penalized for violating noise ordinances, which apply just as well to short-term and long-term residents.
- untog 12y agoSo the German tourist that comes to Midtown Manhattan is going to be tracked down all the way back in Europe for violating a noise ordinance, is he? Come on.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoIf you can't track down the resident, fine the property owner as the ultimately responsible party.
- untog 12y agoRight - the noise has already happened, though. To choose a more permanent example - property damage. If the tourist damages the property, you make the property owner pay for repairs. OK. Maybe AirBnB can help the property owner track down the tourist to get the money for repairs, maybe not. But the point is that the damage still happened in the first place - a longer term tenant that faces their neighbours every day would be far less likely to have done the damage in the first place.
- CocaKoala 12y agoBut if you hold the tenant responsible for the actions of their subletters, then they'll be less likely to sublet their room (or at least be more discerning about who they let sublet); the end result is that the issue diminishes.
- baddox 12y ago> Right - the noise has already happened, though. Well, that's a physical limitation. Arrow of time and whatnot. It also applies to all penalties. Of course, the point of the penalty is not simply to raise money or get revenge after a rule is broken. The purpose is to disincentivize breaking the rule in the first place.
- baddox 12y agoFine the property owner either way. If the tenants were there with the property owner's permission, it's the property owner's responsibility.
- zorpner 12y agoThis is a naive view of how quiet-enjoyment-type laws are enforced. It can take weeks to months to bring action against neighbors for violating noise ordinances (if they even exist). When I moved into my current SF apartment, I verified with the management that short-term rentals were forbidden in the lease terms, and that they'd be willing to take action against tenants who violated that clause. I have no desire to live in a building occupied by people who have no incentive to live in harmony.
- baddox 12y ago> It can take weeks to months to bring action against neighbors for violating noise ordinances (if they even exist). Then that applies equally to short-term and long-term occupants. Of course, the point of the rules and penalties is to disincentivize the behavior, not just to have recourse after the behavior occurs. Assuming there is a reliable process of enforcing the penalties, and the penalties are set appropriately, they should function to sufficiently disincentivize the behavior.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoThis seems similar to people who admire an idyllic view of other people's trees from their house, and then complain when the actual owner of that other property takes down the trees that were providing that view. "Not neighborly" is not a crime; you can't even sensibly define what it would mean, other than "don't do anything I don't like". Which leads directly into NIMBY. There are long-term residents who hold similar views about not particularly caring to know or interact with their neighbors, and that's not against the law either. (Also, does "quiet-enjoyment-type laws" sound like dystopian doublespeak to anyone else, or is it just me?) For the record, though, there's nothing wrong with the owner of an apartment building prohibiting the renters or owners of the apartments from subletting them via AirBnB or any other means. It's perfectly fine for them to say "don't rent out your place or we'll kick you out". So if they want to construct an apartment building that caters to long-term residents who object to living near short-term residents, they can. And if they want to rent out their apartments on a short-term basis, or let their tenants do so, to the possible detriment of their ability to attract long-term residents, they can do that too.
- baddox 12y agoOr, more likely, because the actual property owner would be fined or otherwise penalized for allowing the violation of the local rules. So the question becomes Why would owners offer short-term rental at all, or without some reliable vetting process?
- prostoalex 12y agoI think that's the problem - there's no effective mechanism to penalize a short-term tenant for excessive noise, parking violations, smoking on premises, etc. Faced with lack of efficient mechanisms, HOAs or city councils after hearing a few horror stories just throw the baby with the bathwater by outlawing all short-term stays, even if 99% of short-term stays are quiet decent non-confrontational tenants.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> I think that's the problem - there's no effective mechanism to penalize a short-term tenant for excessive noise, parking violations, smoking on premises, etc. Sure there is: make the property owner ultimately responsible, if they're not already. Then watch how fast they actively seek out solutions that pass on more liability to the tenant. > Faced with lack of efficient mechanisms, HOAs or city councils after hearing a few horror stories just throw the baby with the bathwater by outlawing all short-term stays, even if 99% of short-term stays are quiet decent non-confrontational tenants. Yeah, most regulation seems to be reactionary in response to a small fraction of high-profile incidents. "How do we not make the news? How do we not get blamed?" See also airport security.
- prostoalex 12y agoMost HOAs are kinda toothless on the enforcement side, as any financial penalties could be met with property owner's "document it and prove it" response, at which point there's little recourse. Speaking from experience here, having been a member in an HOA with a smoking tenant nearby (nothing related to AirBnB, this was a long-term lease).
- oh_sigh 12y agoThe worst penalty you could incur via air bnb is a negative feedback. I'm almost certain there is no method in place for enforcing monetary fines for breaking rules. Then again, how would one even report rule breaking? If you live next to an illegal air bnb unit, how do you inform air bnb that your local rules are being broken? How do you show them what your local rules are? How do you prove they are being broken?
- icanhackit 12y agoJust throwing out an idea, not a particularly well-formed one: Air BnB could allow you to enter your address on the site if you wish to report noise or disturbance. Without informing you who the occupant is or forcing you to submit personal ID beyond your unit or house number; based on your proximity to any booked Air BnB properties the nearest user would get a ping via SMS and if they continue to make noise the lessor gets a ping via SMS. The ping would be done without letting the reporter know any information other than a nearby user has been notified. The lessor SMS could include the phone number of the lessee so that they don't have to go hunting for the details and can act on the information quickly. You'd need to set it up in such a way as to prevent someone spamming the system with random addresses or ceaselessly pinging the lessee/lessor.
- rodgerd 12y ago> Because they could be fined or otherwise penalized for violating noise ordinances, Oooh, I'm so scared of fines from a local authority in a town I'm visiting for two days and never coming back to again after I return to my own country on the other side of the world.