4 ms·
Is it reasonable that hotels and my friend with a couple of spare bedrooms in his house should have to compete on a level playing field in terms of regulation,
by marssaxman 12y ago
Is it reasonable that hotels and my friend with a couple of spare bedrooms in his house should have to compete on a level playing field in terms of regulation, inspection, taxation, and the like? Because as far as I can tell Airbnb does not operate anything; they are just a booking service for people who rent out spare bedrooms. It doesn't seem reasonable that my friend with the big house should have to jump through all the same hoops as the professionals running the Marriott or whatever.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWell, as the guy staying there, I'd like to have SOME guarantee that the place isn't unsafe, unsanitary, cheating me or spying on me. So as a consumer, then yes I do want them to jump through all the hoops.
- mason240 12y agoThen don't go to AirBnB places. Go to hotels. It really is that simple. Don't deprive other people of choice because you don't want to choose.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWe can say that, but it doesn't end there. Paying folks money means I get value in return. There will be disputes about the value; lawyers get involved. The whole hotel-thing is 100's of years of working that out in law. Now we start over? Just because AirBnB is cool, and we want it to succeed? I don't think this is going to end well.
- hackuser 12y ago> Then don't go to AirBnB places. Go to hotels. That doesn't address safety and taxation issues.
- mason240 12y agoIt does. If you are concerned with safety issues, then don't go there.
- hackuser 12y ago> It does. If you are concerned with safety issues, then don't go there. The 'free market' doesn't address safety well; that's why we have regulations. For example, it's not sufficient to say, 'if you are concerned about the safety of this restaurant's food, don't eat there'. No consumer has enough information to make that judgment reliably, and many consumers have additional challenges (consider the elderly, travelers from other countries who lack English or culture literacy, etc.). Also, the remedy (the Airbnb host gets bad reviews) is too late if someone is injured or loses their property; the system has failed at that point.
- humanrebar 12y ago> The 'free market' doesn't address safety well; that's why we have regulations. We also have bonding, insurance and civil liability, which serve the same purpose in a more flexible way.
- hackuser 12y ago> We also have bonding, insurance and civil liability, which serve the same purpose in a more flexible way. Those solutions are useful, but only sometimes work and when they do they only provide money after the fact. In many cases, such as injury, death, or crippling fraud (e.g., an elderly retiree loses their home and savings), that's not sufficient.
- humanrebar 12y agoThe way insurance works is that risky behavior leads to higher premiums. Insuring a sports car is more expensive because studies show risky driving is associated with sports cars. Hosts that don't treat neighbors respectfully or guests safely will quickly see bonds confiscated and premiums raised until they are out of the business. Likewise, insurers often provide discounts for good behavior like taking safety courses, a history without incidents, installing anti theft devices, etc. And requiring insurance also gives neighbors a recourse (payouts from the policy) if the block is set on for or something (though there are already laws and regulations about that sort of thing).
- eropple 12y agoThat choice inflicts negative externalities on everyone else. I understand that the concept of negative externalities throws a wrench into this sort of shallow pseudoeconomic theorizing, but they exist and must be considered in a credible discussion.
- marssaxman 12y agoFor an opportunity to stay in some random person's spare bedroom, a web site with reviews from people who have stayed there previously sounds like a perfectly reasonable level of guarantee. Requiring people to act like professional hoteliers in their spare time seems likely to kill the whole project, which would be a shame as it makes travel both cheaper and more fun.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThe cheaper part is the issue. How cheap? What can they skip? Smoke alarms? Clean bathrooms? Hotels have to meet a minimum bar. Does AirBnB? Why not? This is going to end up in court sooner or later. Does hotel law cover it? If not, we have to write those all over again, for AirBnB.
- marssaxman 12y agoWho cares? These are hypothetical problems. Don't fix what ain't broke.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoJust yesterday somebody posted about their house getting trashed by AirBnB renters. So its started already. Who's insurance is responsible? Is it a civil matter, or criminal? What rights do the owners have, to charge the renter's credit card for damages?
- AnkhMorporkian 12y agoAirBnB takes out insurance for that very purpose, damages are insured up to 1 million dollars.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoUntil its criminal; then its a matter of law.
- 12y ago
- hackuser 12y ago> It doesn't seem reasonable that my friend with the big house should have to jump through all the same hoops as the professionals running the Marriott or whatever. I agree. The regulations were written for a different market; new regulations are needed that provide a level playing field for competition, which means hotels aren't at a 14% price disadvantage and short-term rentals can cost-effectively comply. It's going to take some innovation. (I'm assuming the hotel regulations are too onerous for short-term rentals, but I don't know much about them.)
- marssaxman 12y agoMaybe. All I see right now is the traditional scream of the incumbent big business freaking out that a clever new business model is threatening the service monopoly underlying their profit model. The safety concerns are maybes and could-bes.
- hackuser 12y ago> All I see right now is the traditional scream of the incumbent big business freaking out Yes, I see that too, but they and the public do have valid concerns. > The safety concerns are maybes and could-bes. All safety issues are maybes and could-bes, if you are doing it right. 'Why do we pay for this anti-malware system? We haven't had a virus in years!'