4 ms·
I would like to see some real numbers. Finance is 8% of the entire GDP of the US. The transaction volume will eventually go up unrelated to mining power. It s
by CyberDildonics 12y ago
I would like to see some real numbers. Finance is 8% of the entire GDP of the US. The transaction volume will eventually go up unrelated to mining power. It seems like a waste to people who don't understand systems of incentives, but it is a small and insignificant price to pay for more ideal money.
How much electricity is really being wasted? Economics works even if some people's reaction is an emotional one instead of data driven.
- kens 12y agoOne paper estimates that the power consumption of Bitcoin mining is approximately equal to the power consumption of Ireland. My own estimate is that it is the same as the power consumption of Cambodia. Either way, Bitcoin's power usage is basically insane, considering that the transaction volume could literally be handled by a Raspberry Pi running a SQL database. Ref: https://karlodwyer.github.io/publications/pdf/bitcoin_KJOD_2014.pdf https://karlodwyer.github.io/publications/pdf/bitcoin_KJOD_2...
- CyberDildonics 12y agoThe power consumption of all of Ireland? Let's all use our best judgment to really think that through.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> It seems like a waste to people who don't understand systems of incentives, Well, it may be that I don't understand incentives here, but it seems to me that Bitcoin is constructed to incentivize wasting exponentially growing amounts of power. Yes, legacy financial system is a waste, too, but we should be striving to stabilize and reduce that waste instead of constructing an engine that could happpily raise it to an unprecedented amount.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoThe missing factor is that it isn't exponential. Right now block rewards are the mining incentive. Eventually transaction volume will go up much higher at no cost to the miners, which will flip the transaction volume to power used ratio. Legacy financial systems are not just wasteful, they are horrendously wasteful and incredibly inept. It may be the case the competing crypto currencies take over or coexist with bitcoin, but they will have to overcome its substantial network effect and development lead (although it is open source of course).
- vectorpush 12y ago> It seems like a waste to people who don't understand systems of incentives, The implication that bitcoin critics are simply incapable of understanding bitcoin's "system of incentives" is laughably condescending as well as totally inaccurate. > but it is a small and insignificant price to pay for more ideal money. I don't think "decentralized" necessarily translates to "more ideal". Certainly, it's not ideal for most people given all the other drawbacks that come with bitcoin (difficult to spend, difficult to secure, subject to price fluctuations, subject to privacy concerns, vulnerable to critical mistakes like sending money to the wrong address or losing a wallet in a hard-drive crash). Bitcoin is only "more ideal" if you want to perform transactions outside the legacy system; a real use-case, but not a very popular one.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoDecentralized isn't why it has better properties of ideal money. Interestingly the winklevoss twins have made by far the best presentation of the value of money.