4 ms·
Bitcoin is an environmental disaster. What a horrendous waste burning electricity and real, non-renewable natural resources to generate these tokens. For all pe
by ForHackernews 12y ago
Bitcoin is an environmental disaster. What a horrendous waste burning electricity and real, non-renewable natural resources to generate these tokens. For all people complain about the legacy financial system, bitcoin is a real zero-sum game where the more miners join, the harder the block difficulty gets, and the more coal gets burnt.
- ikeboy 12y agoAs long as you capture the heat, it's not a waste. Also, how much energy does the legacy finance system waste? All the energy spent to build banks, armored trucks, secured networks, etc. A couple years back they spent a couple hundred million to build a cable connecting New York and London for financial data because it was 5 milliseconds faster than what they had before.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoFirst of all, I don't think we should be talking about waste in terms of money, but energy used. Surely, that NY-London cable was energetically expensive, but a big chunk on that money was probably created out of arbitrary whatever-they-do-on-Wall-Street and used to pay off people and various non-energy-related costs (e.g. land laws). Secondly, as wasteful as our current financial system is, it doesn't seem to have that strong growth factor built in. Making and maintaining bitcoins depends on ever increasing energy use; energy, which is wasted in the most literal sense - burned out on nonsense computations just to show that you had enough of it to burn. I think we should treat the energy used on financial system as upkeep - unavoidable cost we have to pay because as a species, we suck at coordinating, but that we'd do best to minimize.
- ikeboy 12y agoFirst, in terms of raw energy, I'm pretty sure finance has bitcoin beat. Second, the energy used by bitcoin doesn't need to increase. The cost of all the energy used will tend towards the price of the subsidy+fees, and the subsidy is being phased out. In a few decades the subsidy will be almost gone. If bitcoin completely replaced finance, would it really use more energy than saved by finance stopping? And you didn't address the point about capturing the heat.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI'm talking about energy, not costs. Money is arbitrary, joules are not, and you can't plug your computer to a stash of dollars and have it run. Generating energy comes at a cost to ecology, to workers and the supply is not unlimited. RE capturing heat - heat is a low-grade form of energy and electricity is high-grade. You can't power a machine from heat at efficiency levels of electricity. And if you want an electric heater, buy a heat pump - these run at 500% (!) electric to thermal conversion efficiency (by using 1kW of electricity to move 5kW of heat around).
- ikeboy 12y agoI'm talking about energy as well. In order to project how much energy bitcoin will use, you need to understand the incentives. Could you clarify what you meant by increasing energy use?
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIsn't it true, that as time goes on, mining gets harder (= more energy intensive), so if you want to earn bitcoins you need to invest increasingly growing amount of energy? Isn't it also true that this process of mining needs to continue to ensure the integrity and trustworthiness of the blockchain?
- ikeboy 12y agoNo. Mining adjusts so that it always takes 10 minutes to find a block on average. This can happen on a single computer, or on a billion. If the price of bitcoin keeps on increasing, there's a larger inventive to mine, which will cause the difficulty to increase. The marginal profit of mining will always tend towards zero, and the total spent on trying to mine will tend towards subsidy plus fees. The subsidy halfs every so often.
- kinghajj 12y agoMining only appears always to increase as time goes on because Bitcoin is increasing in popularity, but the protocol itself doesn't mandate that at all. Like ikeboy said, difficulty is adjusted to keep the average time to find a new block at about 10 minutes. The network is perfectly content to let the rate stay still if no new computational power is added to the network. https://blockchain.info/charts/hash-rate?showDataPoints=false&show_header=true&daysAverageString=1×pan=all&scale=1&address= https://blockchain.info/charts/hash-rate?showDataPoints=fals... As you can see, the increase in hash rate has been stagnating for nearly a year at this point.
- kinghajj 12y agoYou could say that about any number of human activities, though. "Geez, all these game conventions use so much power, can you imagine how much coal is being used to power all these lights and booths right now?" If anything, having the monetary system tied to the power efficiency of computing devices should greatly incentivize increasing their efficiency further. Edit: Downvotes aren't supposed to be used for disagreements, but whatever.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoI would like to see some real numbers. Finance is 8% of the entire GDP of the US. The transaction volume will eventually go up unrelated to mining power. It seems like a waste to people who don't understand systems of incentives, but it is a small and insignificant price to pay for more ideal money. How much electricity is really being wasted? Economics works even if some people's reaction is an emotional one instead of data driven.
- kens 12y agoOne paper estimates that the power consumption of Bitcoin mining is approximately equal to the power consumption of Ireland. My own estimate is that it is the same as the power consumption of Cambodia. Either way, Bitcoin's power usage is basically insane, considering that the transaction volume could literally be handled by a Raspberry Pi running a SQL database. Ref: https://karlodwyer.github.io/publications/pdf/bitcoin_KJOD_2014.pdf https://karlodwyer.github.io/publications/pdf/bitcoin_KJOD_2...
- CyberDildonics 12y agoThe power consumption of all of Ireland? Let's all use our best judgment to really think that through.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> It seems like a waste to people who don't understand systems of incentives, Well, it may be that I don't understand incentives here, but it seems to me that Bitcoin is constructed to incentivize wasting exponentially growing amounts of power. Yes, legacy financial system is a waste, too, but we should be striving to stabilize and reduce that waste instead of constructing an engine that could happpily raise it to an unprecedented amount.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoThe missing factor is that it isn't exponential. Right now block rewards are the mining incentive. Eventually transaction volume will go up much higher at no cost to the miners, which will flip the transaction volume to power used ratio. Legacy financial systems are not just wasteful, they are horrendously wasteful and incredibly inept. It may be the case the competing crypto currencies take over or coexist with bitcoin, but they will have to overcome its substantial network effect and development lead (although it is open source of course).