3 ms·
The problem with agile is that it requires a completely different way to think about productivity and company finances not just in the team but the entire conne
by ThomPete 12y ago
The problem with agile is that it requires a completely different way to think about productivity and company finances not just in the team but the entire connected reality of a project.
Agile solves a conceptual issue which is it creates a more effective feedback loop that keeps everyone more informed than they used to be with classic waterfall models.
The problem though is that the financial reality isn't following the logic of the agile model and so whether you are trying to use the agile model for customer projects or internally in your organization you are still a child of the the overarching financial reality which dictates how companies are measured and budgets created.
Agile is great for innovation where there is no deadline and no limited budgets. It creates a false sense of effectiveness when it comes to projects with deadlines and budgets.
At the end of the day all it does is allow you to say earlier to those you have to deliver to that they aren't going to get everything they asked for at the same price as what they thought they were getting.
- janee 12y ago> "Agile is great for innovation where there is no deadline and no limited budgets" that rings very true with me. I'm nearing the end of a 3 year project where scrum was prescribed and followed, but the truth is we've basically shoehorned agile practices into a waterfall model because of business needs. My experience with agile projects is probably far removed from how it should be implemented, but it still feels like it's fundamentally flawed to address business needs which rely on fixed scope and accurate estimates from the start of the project succeed (e.g. critical 3rd party tools being end-of-lifed, product mandates beyond company control, renewing client licenses based on feature completion). I guess until something better comes along, I'm stuck with being told to do some strange type of scrumfall/water-gile.