5 ms·
Actually, the best way to fight this would be to fund people to break the DRM blob. What better way to drive home the uselessness of DRM than to have zillions
by bsder 12y ago
Actually, the best way to fight this would be to fund people to break the DRM blob.
What better way to drive home the uselessness of DRM than to have zillions of people having an automatic plugin that bypasses DRM everywhere it runs?
- backprojection 12y agoWouldn't this violate the dmca? If it's not something people can get with minimal effort, then millions of people are not going to use it. The ad-blocking plugins are so successful because their so easy to get. If something's illegal to distribute, then it's sufficiently inconvenient to obtain (tormenting, etc.) that most people won't bother. http://lesswrong.com/lw/f1/beware_trivial_inconveniences/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/f1/beware_trivial_inconveniences/
- fulafel 12y agoJust develop & distribute it from outside the US.
- forgottenpass 12y agoNo, that is just an iteration of a cat and mouse game. It doesn't matter if the technically-weak position can be overcome when it is used by parties with exponentially more money and legal power. Fighting this fight on technical grounds alone is a surefire way to accelerate the inevitability of locked down computing platforms that restrict what the owner is capable of.
- slang800 12y agoUnless it's easier to break DRM than it is to build a new implementation... Then we're just causing the companies that invest in DRM to lose more money than the companies that respect freedom. I can't say from experience how difficult it is to break and implement the DRM used on the web, but if it's anything like the DRM used in videogames, it should be doable in a couple weeks (with enough motivation).
- na85 12y agoThe end game is that DRM companies aggressively lobby government to pass laws making it illegal to circumvent a digital lock. Then if you are found to have bypassed their trivial code they throw the book at you. No technical solution required.
- shmerl 12y agoDRM blob is probably already broken (and if not, it will be soon enough). Those who use DRM do it despite knowing that it's useless for preventing copying. So breaking that DRM won't help that. It's some kind of distortion of the mind, not the logical reasoning here. Of course there are those who use DRM for simply sinister control purposes (i.e. DMCA-1201 supporters and the like). Those wouldn't care even if you clearly show them that DRM has negative, not positive effect on reducing piracy.
- Sir_Substance 12y agoThe best way to fight this would be to stop buying content from companies that use DRM. God damn, get some self control people.
- ticviking 12y agoBut sir, DRM cannot and will not be the sole factor in determining what is worth buying. I will take DRM into account, but I'm not going to let my opposition to DRM cripple my access to Media as much as the worst case nightmare DRM scenario would do. In some fields DRM is known to be bad and I have excellent competitors making top quality experiences without DRM. Gaming, and particularly strategy games have a glut of amazing content like this. In Film though my choices are pay-per-performance(Which I have gleefully several times for Ultron already), or accept that the best work in genres I enjoy is behind DRM. In Music I've no idea, I honestly just rent access to music without ads from google, and play whatever the playlist generator comes up with.
- Sir_Substance 12y ago>DRM cannot and will not be the sole factor in determining what is worth buying. Of course it can, that's at your sole discretion. If it will not be, that's a personal decision, but game of thrones is not oxygen, it's a TV show. You could always take up hiking, if nothing else.
- ticviking 12y agoEven if I make it a hard requirement, it cannot be the only factor. I choose to place DRM-free below "Will I enjoy it" and "Do I really want store a physical copy" in how I rank things. It's clear you advocate a different set of priorities. That's fine, but pretending that differing priorities are the same as a lack of self-control is dismissive, and annoying. Particularly when you seem to advocate a complete boycott of all companies that make use of DRM at all. I have a quite lovely bound set of game of thrones. It's totally DRM free ;) You're quite right about hiking though, my sanity and health would both probably benfit from the increased activity and reduced screen-time.