2 ms·
> A collection of statements, all of which are false, is not guaranteed to be consistent. Hmm. You are right, to be sure. I guess I was carelessly generalisi
by JadeNB 12y ago
> A collection of statements, all of which are false, is not guaranteed to be consistent.
Hmm. You are right, to be sure. I guess I was carelessly generalising from the fact that anything follows from a false statement.
- dragonwriter 12y agoI think you are misremembering the rule that any statement of the form if X then Y is true if X is false as "anything follows from a false statement" which isn't correct.
- JadeNB 12y ago> any statement of the form if X then Y is true if X is false This is indeed precisely what I meant by "anything (Y) follows from a false statement (X)"—although maybe "everything follows from a false statement" sounds better. This is precisely why an inconsistent logic can prove everything. This principle is sometimes also called ex falso quodlibet (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex_falso_quodlibet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex_falso_quodlibet). Of course, giving it another name doesn't make it any more (or less) true, but it may make it sound more familiar and less dodgy! I know I muffed up the first statement pretty badly, which doesn't inspire confidence; but, as a mathematician, I'm pretty sure about this one. :-)