4 ms·
What I don't get is why some of these climate scientists have been so antagonistic to those like Anthony Watts and Steve McIntyre who question the data and simp
by cwan 17y ago
What I don't get is why some of these climate scientists have been so antagonistic to those like Anthony Watts and Steve McIntyre who question the data and simply ask for the data sets to be made public. To the credit of RealClimate they seem to be acknowledging the need for greater transparency that would allay some of the allegations of collusion.
What is a bit troubling though is RealClimate could be interpreted as defending the status quo and the monopoly on data in their response to comments. They seem to suggest we should simply accept the studies if they are peer reviewed. They create something of a straw man in saying that there is no evidence of a global conspiracy (I'm really not sure how many serious people think that one really exists nor is it necessary to believe that there is one in order to question the data and the policy responses being crafted).
They also don't address the allegation of whether some of these scientists have started with the conclusions and searched for data to show that it exists - particularly given some of the substance in some of these emails. Surely, given how heated and politicized the debate has become there should be some acknowledgment that there could be confirmation bias. Is (more) empiricism too much to ask for?
- chrisb 17y agoJust to comment on the often repeated claim of the unavailability of the data - try visiting: http://www-pcmdi.llnl.gov/ipcc/about_ipcc.php http://www-pcmdi.llnl.gov/ipcc/about_ipcc.php - contains all the models used in the IPCC AR4. http://tamino.wordpress.com/climate-data-links/ http://tamino.wordpress.com/climate-data-links/ - contains a huge amount of climate data. http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/ccr/ammann/millennium/CODES_MBH.html http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/ccr/ammann/millennium/CODES_MBH.html - An independend re-evaluation of a climate reconstruction. http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/pubs/mann2008/mann2008.html http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/pubs/mann2008/mann2008.html - Full data for a late 2008 reconstruction. Data is available - maybe part of the problem is the complexity and quantity of the data.
- jacoblyles 17y agoWhen I have time and climateaudit is back up, I am going to reply to this comment with specific instances of McIntyre being refused the data he would like in order to replicate studies. I would like for you to tell me if you think that behavior is befitting the scientific community or not.
- antonovka 17y agoAn ignorant, unqualified gadfly complaining about a lack of assistance and collaboration from working scientists is not a compelling argument.
- robotrout 17y agoWow! Unfortunately, your attitude today, exactly reflects the problem. Obviously, the gentleman in question is anything but what you claim him to be. Read your post, and then perhaps do a little soul searching about what science is really about.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jacoblyles 17y agoThe only people afraid of sunlight are those people with something to be ashamed of. I wasn't aware that you needed to be "qualified" to be allowed to reproduce mathematical models.
- antonovka 17y agoThe only people afraid of sunlight are those people with something to be ashamed of. There are plenty of reasons to be afraid of exposing internal communications due to the vagaries of political processes and vendettas. To claim otherwise is naive, disingenuous, or both. I wasn't aware that you needed to be "qualified" to be allowed to reproduce mathematical models. I'm sure that if he just wasn't being kept down by those evil climate scientists, he'd prove them all wrong.
- potatolicious 17y agoThe only people afraid of sunlight are those people with something to be ashamed of. If you have nothing to hide, why won't you let me search your car?
- cakeface 17y ago"They also don't address the allegation of whether some of these scientists have started with the conclusions and searched for data to show that it exists" Isn't this sort of normal? Present a hypothesis and then set out to see if it is true.
- damienkatz 17y agoNo, you present a hypothesis and try prove it wrong. And best science is done when many people try to prove it wrong. Less scrutiny is not better science.
- DarkShikari 17y agoWild accusations by people with political agendas hardly counts as "scientific scrutiny".
- anamax 17y ago> Wild accusations by people with political agendas hardly counts as "scientific scrutiny". Actually, it does. More to the point, you're cherry-picking the skeptics. The skeptics found that all of the ocean-rising data is due to a single measurement station. The skeptics found that the "hottest year in the US" data was wrong. The skeptics found that the hockey stick wasn't. And so on. And no, motivation doesn't actually matter. Only facts and interpretation do.
- DarkShikari 17y agoMore to the point, you're cherry-picking the skeptics. The skeptics found that all of the ocean-rising data is due to a single measurement station. The skeptics found that the "hottest year in the US" data was wrong. The skeptics found that the hockey stick wasn't. And so on. You don't have to be a "skeptic" to look for faults in scientific papers. That's how the process is supposed to work. And no, motivation doesn't actually matter. Only facts and interpretation do. Of course it matters. Ulterior motives in science have reliably blinded people from facts for hundreds of years. Just look at how long it took people to agree that tobacco was harmful--and how much money was being paid by the tobacco companies to try to avoid that conclusion. Even if every single thing that someone says is factual, they may have committed dishonesty by omission of relevant information. Merely validating the words of someone with ulterior motives cannot ensure that you have not been misled. If you cannot trust someone's motivations, you cannot trust them at all.