3 ms·
I think that this is Karunamon (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9534654)'s https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9534654)'s point: an inconsistent collecti
by JadeNB 12y ago
I think that this is Karunamon (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9534654)'s https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9534654)'s point: an inconsistent collection of statements contains at least one false statement; but a collection of statements, all of which are false, is guaranteed to be consistent, so consistency is no guarantor of truth (and indeed may obtain with more falsehood in place than inconsistency).
- dragonwriter 12y ago> a collection of statements, all of which are false, is guaranteed to be consistent "Hillary Clinton is exactly 8 years old", "Hillary Clinton is exactly 9 years old". A collection of statements, all of which are false, is not guaranteed to be consistent.
- JadeNB 12y ago> A collection of statements, all of which are false, is not guaranteed to be consistent. Hmm. You are right, to be sure. I guess I was carelessly generalising from the fact that anything follows from a false statement.
- dragonwriter 12y agoI think you are misremembering the rule that any statement of the form if X then Y is true if X is false as "anything follows from a false statement" which isn't correct.
- JadeNB 12y ago> any statement of the form if X then Y is true if X is false This is indeed precisely what I meant by "anything (Y) follows from a false statement (X)"—although maybe "everything follows from a false statement" sounds better. This is precisely why an inconsistent logic can prove everything. This principle is sometimes also called ex falso quodlibet (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex_falso_quodlibet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex_falso_quodlibet). Of course, giving it another name doesn't make it any more (or less) true, but it may make it sound more familiar and less dodgy! I know I muffed up the first statement pretty badly, which doesn't inspire confidence; but, as a mathematician, I'm pretty sure about this one. :-)