2 ms·
Problem is that Google, HN, "share" links etc is free advertising. Media says that certain discovery channels (Google) should be let in, while other (HN, emaile
by bdcravens 12y ago
Problem is that Google, HN, "share" links etc is free advertising. Media says that certain discovery channels (Google) should be let in, while other (HN, emailed links, etc) shouldn't. This extension only equalizes that.
Perhaps a better extension would be to hide organic search results in Google for pay-walled content providers, while leaving AdWords links intact. In the interests of protecting profit-based interests.
Additionally, Facebook should require paywalled content providers to pay users that use their integrated comments or click a like button, as we certainly don't want free buzz, as that would violate the profit-driven flow of information.
- manigandham 12y agoPublishers are all for-profit, they just choose different monetization models. Whether it's ads or paywall, content is content. Why should it be ok for Google to discriminate which content is shown by the host's business model instead of the relevance and quality of the content?
- bdcravens 12y agoI'm cool with content providers charging. What I'm not ok with is some discovery channels getting free access to that content, while others don't. As far as Google is concerned, they're a business, not a public utility. If a content provider can choose what and whom to show to, so can Google. The ethical approach would be to not be indexed by Google, but rather, use a pure paid ads approach (or a revenue sharing model). To not have a universal interaction model is deceptive. (I search on Google, see an article, click, and use your nifty sharing widget, but those I share with are prompted to subscribe, and now I look bad)