2 ms·
This is the sort of thing that can really only be answered by asking you to clearly specify the alternative you are proposing. You want a world in which... what
by jerf 12y ago
This is the sort of thing that can really only be answered by asking you to clearly specify the alternative you are proposing. You want a world in which... what... being altruistic makes you feel bad? Isn't altruism supposed to be good? Shouldn't doing right things feel right? (I grant this is not always the case, but we're talking normative here... shouldn't good things feel good?)
How crazy would it be to say "I'm going to build an AI that is selfless and altruistic. When it performs an act of altruism, it will be penalized."? That's not going to end well.
Do we want a world in which it doesn't make you feel anything at all, but by sheer force of rationality our apparently-disembodied consciousnesses choose to do good things? Well... presumably they're going to do it because it creates good outcomes, not merely because altruism is somehow intrinsically good in some abstract, unquestionable Platonic sense.
Altruism just doesn't work as its own moral principle somehow abstractly severed from its effects. We desire it precisely because it has good effects. This is not separable from the desirability of altruism... if altruistic behaviors simply had bad effects we would not continue to advocating for them anyhow because altruism was simply its own moral good, we would call those actions evil.
I'd propose that "true selflessness" of the sort that many people seem to propose in this sort of discussion is merely a fuzzy concept that has no possible manifestation in the real world. Clarifying the concept of "true selflessness" clarifies it it right out of existence.