5 ms·
It's quite a bit absurd to complain about technical solutions which fullfill the needs of users. If a source of income revolves around annoying users into payin
by scrollaway 12y ago
It's quite a bit absurd to complain about technical solutions which fullfill the needs of users. If a source of income revolves around annoying users into paying and for them not to find a way around such annoyances, don't expect it to last forever.
In this model, I consider the whole tactic to be publishers relying too much on Google's policy in the first place. If they change that policy, said publishers are screwed. Anything that depends on a third party is doomed to begin with.
These things are temporary income at best. Publishers should not just "take the win and go home"; keep looking for other, better solutions.
- eli 12y ago> It's quite a bit absurd to complain about technical solutions which fullfill the needs of users. Nonsense. Users want everything for free, instantly and with no ads. I would like my sandwiches from the shop downstairs to be free all the time. But it's not cool to forge stamps on a loyalty card.
- scrollaway 12y ago> Users want everything for free, instantly and with no ads. And where's the source to that little strawman of yours? I'm sure users also want hot threesomes and a million dollars.
- eli 12y agoI think we're perhaps talking past each other. You want a source that says people prefer getting things for free over paying for them?
- manigandham 12y agoLife and business is all about 3rd parties and working with and against them. It's quite easy to say that things should just be better but it's not like all these publishers are stupid and just sitting around not trying to come up with better solutions. This is actually the best we have at this moment without a massive shift in how the web works. The fact is that the internet makes things very easy to take without repercussions. Physically walking into a store and taking something has consequences but a quick hack on the browser is basically unnoticeable. The abilities and democracy of the internet architecture facilitates the extraction of content without compensation. Just because it's easy though, doesn't make it "right".
- ryandrake 12y agoThere's no taking going on here. Taking something implies a transfer of possession, leaving one party no longer in possession of that thing. My browsing a web page does not result in such an outcome.
- manigandham 12y agoTaking is not zero-sum. Virtual existence does not disqualify ownership or rights. Content is intangible but still carries value, the same way millions of people can have a copy of a song but it is still property. Receiving that value in the form of content without compensation, either by viewing ads or paying money, is still "taking" it against the wishes of the provider.
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoReminds me of the very old joke about software: Software is like VD you can give it away and you've still got it
- scrollaway 12y ago> Just because it's easy though, doesn't make it "right". If something is both easy and rewarding for those who do it, don't base your business on trusting people not to do it. Consequentially, don't base your morality code on a notion of "people shouldn't do it". They shouldn't do it because it hurts businesses, but it only hurts businesses because they're foolish enough to make the first mistake.
- manigandham 12y agoI believe your foundation for this argument is flawed and doesn't answer my statement: just because something is easy, does not make it right. "People shouldn't do it" is the fundamental way laws and regulations work. You shouldn't damage property or steal items or assault people. But you can. Very easily. And depending on when/where/how you can probably get away with it. Does that make it ok? Actions in the physical world have very lasting effects and, these days, leave a big trail which allows the proper authorities to catch the bad actor and dispense justice (the topic of what is proper justice being out of scope for this thread). The digital world is much harder with things happening instantaneously with very little if any trail. If publishers could catch you, they would. Realistically, they just can't. But this lapse in their abilities does not empower and justify your abilities to do what should not be done. Business models are a completely separate topic and, yes, it's usually good to align the model with normal consumer action. However, human nature is to always take with the path of least resistance and in the case of "value", to acquire it for nothing in exchange if possible. Most businesses work because they can block any access to that value without a proper exchange. Internet publishing however is very unique in that the very structure of the web which makes it so open is also what makes it impossible to stop and effectively filter anyone. The paywall is one such filter but they have this opening for access to Google listings and let a few users be randomly awarded free content. If there was a way they could be listed on Google without losing their paywall, they would, and this whole situation would be non-existent.