15 ms·
Why so many Dutch people work part time
- petjuh 12y ago> The Netherlands consistently ranks as one of the best places in the world to live. > However, the Netherlands’ record for getting women into top management roles is dire. Isn't happiness what's important? We had a neighbor in our village who had chickens, who always kept the same number of black-feathered and white-feathered chickens. I never saw how this helped with anything. He did it for its own sake I guess. He just liked symmetries and equalities, always keeping his things ordered and aligned, he was kind of obsessive like that.
- goodJobWalrus 12y agoStill, it's interesting that 80% of women and only 20% of men are most happy working part time. Why such large discrepancy?
- bojan 12y agoBecause working part-time you can't really advance very far in your career, and that is expected from men. From women, less so.
- goodJobWalrus 12y agoBut that is the point. Why are women happy to sacrifice their career, for the sake of the family, and men not as much. So, is that really a choice for all these women, or perhaps a necessity?
- rwallace 12y agoI think the point is the reverse. Why are men happy to sacrifice family and everything else that really matters in life for the sake of the rat race, and women not as much? So, is that really a choice for all these men, or perhaps a necessity? What can be done to make it less of a necessity? (As I understand it, some Scandinavian countries have brought in the legal right to paternity leave similar to maternity leave, which strikes me as a good start.)
- wobbleblob 12y agoWhat rat race? The work environment in the NL isn't stressful at all. I would almost call it enjoyable. It's one of the few remarkably pleasant things about living there.
- kuschku 12y agoGermany has a maternity leave law, but people regardless of gender can take it.
- smil 12y agoIt would not be a problem for a male executive to marry a woman working part-time at a café. Would a female executive marry a male who works part-time at a café?
- thisjepisje 12y agoIANAFE, but sure, why not?
- smil 12y agoHave you seen it happen? Heard about it happen? Read about it happening?
- michaelt 12y agoNo, but I could only name about two female senior executives and I have no idea about their marital status.
- smil 12y agoSo, in your experience, it doesn't happen a lot, right? I mean, since you've never, ever heard of it happening.
- beachstartup 12y agoquit dancing around your point. the answer is no, it is exceedingly rare, because women marry up socioeconomically. no matter how successful a woman is, her preference is to marry someone equally or more successful. people tend to provide extreme counter-examples to argue against this, but in the vast majority of cases, it's true.
- tveita 12y agoThis obviously depends on culture, but I think the majority of men and women marry a partner with the same socioeconomical status as themselves. The highly-visible counter-examples tend to come from fields with high gender imbalance, like your stereotypical doctor-nurse or boss-secretary matchups. I think it's reasonable to posit that this effect would be weak or non-existent in an equal society.
- wobbleblob 12y ago"for the sake of the family" It's not for the sake of family. 80% of employed women work part time in the Netherlands. This includes singles, double income no kids, middle aged women whose children have already left home. Only a small percentage of those working part time have young children. When you ask them about it, they try to justify not working more. "Daycare is so expensive" (in another post I try to demonstrate that this excuse doesn't fly), "Working environment is hostile to women" etc etc. If deep down inside people didn't feel at least a bit guilty about not working more, they wouldn't try to justify it. In reality, working part-time is a luxury. Americans prefer the luxury of a large home, two cars, air conditioning, maybe a swimming pool in the yard. Dutch people seem to prefer the luxury of few working hours and long vacations.
- SCHiM 12y agoFeeling guilty about something does not imply guilt in the absolute sense of the word. Also you've proven nothing about anything. I don't see how a single comment can account for any/all complaints that people in the Dutch workforce might have. Living (instead of working) is not a 'luxury', as other might say: work to live, don't live to work.
- wobbleblob 12y agoYou're fighting a straw man, read my comment again without pre conceived bias. A luxury is anything beyond basic necessities like food and shelter. People in poor countries, working 12 hour work days for $10 per day or less, don't have the luxury of working part time. I'm totally fine with someone choosing to work fewer hours or more hours than I'm willing to do, as long as they're capable of supporting themselves. I'm not totally fine with people claiming they would like to work full time, but the government is making it impossible by not subsidizing daycare, out of some kind of conservative bias against working mothers, because that is simply a lie.
- jchrisa 12y agoIt's not a luxury if it makes you more productive to work less.
- saiya-jin 12y agodamn this sounds amazing! working 3 days a week for example, doing adventures & social life in rest (social life = family life). But first let me earn some dough for later...
- roel_v 12y agoMissing the main reason: child care is extremely expensive, to the point where a median full time salary would go wholly to child care when one has two children. For example, I have two children in day care three days a week, and we pay 1200+ euros per month. My friends in Belgium (where I'm from) pay literally 1/10th of that. Those in France and Germany also pay much less than we do, although I don't know by heart exactly how much. The reason child care is not subsidized (much) is the same as that mentioned in the article though - conservative popular opinion on how parents should be home with their children, and that having children in day care 5 days a week is tantamount to neglect.
- davedx 12y agoI thought the kinderopvangtoeslag (childcare benefit) [1] was quite generous if your income wasn't too high? You do have to be very careful your income doesn't change while claiming it, but it is quite a big subsidy, right? (We don't currently claim it and have 1 child in childcare. You're right that it's freaking pricy!) [1] http://www.belastingdienst.nl/wps/wcm/connect/bldcontentnl/belastingdienst/prive/toeslagen/kinderopvangtoeslag/kinderopvangtoeslag_2015/kinderopvangtoeslag_2015 http://www.belastingdienst.nl/wps/wcm/connect/bldcontentnl/b...
- tow21 12y agoThat's hardly unique to the Netherlands though. Childcare is even more expensive in the UK: in London I pay £1200 for one child, and a colleague pays £1700. But the UK doesn't have the same rat of part-time working.
- ibmthrowaway271 12y agoI was paying £1200/month for one child for 3 days/week (5 days/week was £1800/month). Glad that's over with now!
- branchless 12y agoThe problem with kids is they take up space. So they have to be cared for on land. And we have a land price bubble in the UK.
- collyw 12y agoThe article paints this as pretty positive, as such Britain looks good coming in 5th on the graph. In reality many of the jobs created over the last few years in the UK have been low paid zero hours contracts, not because people want the flexibility, but because employers want top pay as little as possible.
- pjc50 12y agoAlso, if you have children and register as self-employed, you can claim Working Families Tax Credit. If you work or claim to work from home the required number of hours, even if you don't earn any money, you get (if my fiddling with the DWP calculator is accurate) £~150 a week, much better than the £~70 from JSA, and you don't have to deal with the Jobcentre any more.
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoSame in the Netherlands. Solution? Create a law that requires employers to hire you on a contract after 3 years of solid work. Now guess what happened :p You get fired after 3 years, so they don't have to give you a contract. Then they hire someone new with less skills, but at least for 3 years they don't have to give a contract and can fire you whenever they need to and of course pay you like a temporary external employee instead of a full-time on contract employee.
- cies 12y agoThis has been reduced to 2 years.
- dazc 12y ago"... but because employers want top pay as little as possible." I think this is true anywhere but especially in the UK they 'can' do this because the benefit system (tax credits, housing benefit, etc) tops up the shortfall.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoIt used to, up to a point. Now people just go into debt, and eventually become homeless and/or bankrupt. After the election, there's no reason at all to think this is going to get better.
- mdemare 12y agoAnother part of this mystery is that Dutch people don't really consider a 32-hour work week to be "part-time". Especially since in most sectors the official full-time work week is only 36 hours. I think I'm the only one of my friends working 40 hours.
- makeitsuckless 12y agoThe popularity of part time work for women may have been a fluke, an accidental mix of choices, culture and circumstances that has lead to the current situation. A situation that is certain downsides. However, the big upside is still underway: it is becoming increasingly normal for men to work part time. Already it's common for men to work no more than 32 hours, that's not even considered part-time anymore. If this trend continuous, the Netherlands is shifting towards a much shorter working week than most countries, without any major upheaval or further government intervention. However much by accident rather than design, it does seem to put the country one step ahead of most when dealing with an economic reality in which full employment for everyone is never going to happen.
- wobbleblob 12y agoThere is just one downside to working part time when you're young that not everyone seems to consider fully. The tax deductible amount you're able to save for retirement is a percentage of your income. Money saved when you're young accumulates more interest. Basically, the less you work now, the more you will have to work later, when you're old. Young people don't seem to realize that there already isn't much AOW (social security) left for them. Unless you're 50+ now (the most powerful voting block is usually exempt from cutbacks), you will not be able to retire at 67. The retirement age is officially raised along with life expectancy. The 20 year old of today will not be eligible for AOW until their early 70's. Because not everyone is physically capable of continuing to work until 70+, and employment opportunities for people over 60 are pretty much zero, you're going to need savings to bridge that gap.
- tunasandwich 12y agoNot necessarily true, a lot of places allow people to work 4 days with a full time salary. In the end its about the job you do, not how many time you spend on it.
- laichzeit0 12y ago> In the end its about the job you do, not how many time you spend on it. Unfortunately most employers don't see it this way. Especially at corporations where the number of employees is large, I mean like > 1000 headcount. It becomes impossible for HR not to completely manage people's time through strict enforcement of working hours policies. They employ you for 40 hours a week and thus expect you to be there for 40 hours a week. If you work for less than 40 hours it means either you're overqualified, i.e. being payed too much, they could replace you with someone that costs less and works slower, or they need to give you more work to do to make up for that 40 hours a week they're paying you for. I hate it.
- mvanvoorden 12y ago"The Dutch government has said that by next year 30% of executive board positions should be held by women..." I wish one day we can do away with this sort of 'reverse' sexism, and I think that next year 100% of executive board positions should be held by capable people, regardless of their sex.
- omginternets 12y ago>I think that next year 100% of executive board positions should be held by capable people, regardless of their sex So, in theory, 50% of capable people should be women, no? edit: If your point is that we shouldn't be positively discriminating to artificially reach equidistribution of men and women in the workplace, then I agree, but your line of argumentation is often used to imply that women are less competent.
- NietTim 12y agoNo. Because woman carry kids when they get pregnant and inadvertently will get behind on work experience compared to their male peers when they have to take time off for birth/etc. (Especially in the Netherlands it's common to take a full year off/more)
- jameshart 12y agoSo clearly your argument is that the most competent people will all be those who have maximized their amount of time in the workplace. We're looking for 70 year olds who never took a day off sick for all board positions. Surely the worst impact of taking time out to have kids should be a slight delay in the career trajectory of the most talented women, not disqualification from board positions because they've now inevitably and irretrievably fallen behind their male peers.
- mvanvoorden 12y agoI don't think so, as more men tend to choose an education that paves an easier path to acquiring a board position. This is not because women are less capable, but because they somehow feel less attracted to this field of work. This of course also has to do with our parents, media and other surroundings teaching us about gender roles and such. It's only since a few years that for example technical studies try to attract more women, as these were before considered 'a man's thing'. It's going to take a few generations for all of this to 'even out' and then we might see 50/50, but it could also result in 70/30 or 30/70, if it turns out that in a gender-neutral unbringing, one gender might be more capable of leadership than another.
- mcv 12y agoIt's worth noting that this article considers anything less than 36 hours per week to be part time, but a lot of Dutch people don't really consider 32 hours part time. It is very common for young dads to work 4 days a week, and people without children often think 4 days is plenty for a work week. For the record, I've worked 32 hour weeks for ages now (and I've only encountered one potential employer who had a problem with that, though they agreed my request was totally reasonable). My wife works 36 hours a week, which is standard in government jobs (as well as in many other places).
- johnward 12y agoI've often thought about trying to negotiate a 4 day work week in the US but it wouldn't be worth it. Since my 40 hours turn into 50 or 60 I could see 32 hours turning into 45 easily.
- furyg3 12y agoHey, I know something about this! I moved from silicon valley to NL about 8 years ago. First off there are two ways to spin this: 1) women are less emancipated in NL because they participate less in the workplace or 2) women are more emancipated because they are able to choose to participate less in the workplace. I first thought #1 was true, but I'm seeing a lot of new fathers taking advantage of Dutch part-time rules by taking a day a week off to participate in child care. So maybe instead of the measure of emancipation being women's values aligning with traditionally 'male' ones, maybe it's that male values are aligning with traditionally 'female' ones. Subjectively I can also ay that the Dutch workplaces I've had the pleasure to experience are both more healthy and more 'efficient', and my previous experience has been exclusively in hard-working silicon valley. Plans are important, meetings are avoided unless necessary (and have agendas!), and there is a focus on getting stuff done so that people can leave at six and be with their families. Overtime is a sign that something has gone terribly wrong, and nobody bothers you while you're on your vacation. This culture allows part-time work to be an option... that is, a 32/36/40-hour contract is actually meaningful. At my previous jobs in the US I wouldn't even think about reducing my hours... a 32 vs 40 hour contract is pointless if you're expected to work 50-60 hours a week, better to take as much money as you can.
- thisjepisje 12y ago"and have agendas!" Are you saying meetings in SV don't have agendas? Gasp
- DamnYuppie 12y agoLOL, too many meetings, to little direction, too many asshats in attendance. That is the general description of meetings I am in, which unfortunately, is frequently.
- acqq 12y agoThanks. I'm from Europe, therefore really needing some explanations (to the opposite direction of the title subject of explaining European logic to the non-European readers): > Overtime is a sign that something has gone terribly wrong Why are there environments which don't think that the "overtime is a sign that something has gone terribly wrong?" How come that workers don't try to stand to their rights? Specifically: > you're expected to work 50-60 hours a week How come, if you sign the contract for e.g. 40 hours? The only thing workers are selling are their work hours, why do they accept to waste 25-50% of that? At least Scott Adams gets it: http://dilbert.com/strip/2011-12-19 http://dilbert.com/strip/2011-12-19
- tobyhinloopen 12y ago"Perhaps the Dutch are happy because they know that one works to live, and that living to work is a perverse waste of life." This is exactly my statement when I told my boss I wanted to work part-time. Now, I only work around 20 up to 32 hours a week. Also, I feel I'm way more productive this way: I only work when I "feel like working". Because of that, I'm way more productive when I work. I have dreams for my future. Doing a day-to-day office job isn't one of them. In my "spare time", I'm converting my hobby and passion into my own company so I can, hopefully, earn money with my hobby and stop working completely. Yes, I'm from the Netherlands.
- jedrek 12y agoI have a friend who does hiring in Berlin for a tech company. He's complained about not being able to find full-time employees. Lots of talented people, surprisingly few want to be locked in for 40-50h/week, especially when they have 4 other quasi-work commitments (playing in a band, working behind a bar once a week, etc) as well.
- hobo_mark 12y agoIf that is what your friend is really complaining about, he might want to expand his talent pool outside of the hipster scene?
- leap_ahead 12y agoThat's because experienced software developers know they can only be productive for 4-5 hours a day and any attempt to forcefully extend this time results in lower quality work and hidden bugs. Then you get a senseless situation on your hands - you first waste a few extra hours to make things bad then you spend additional time to correct your mistakes. You might as well just go home and enjoy extra personal time, to come back fresh and energized the next day. In 20-25 hours per week you can actually accomplish a lot. A 40 hour week will wear you quickly. A 50 hour week can bring you one step closer to a burn-out and possibly damage your health in a long run. Additionally, there might me some cultural issue involved. A few years ago I worked in Germany and the one thing I didn't like about the German workspace is that companies didn't really want their workers to be productive and efficient, they just wanted them to put in all of their official working hours and complete all of the formalities involved, while also frowning upon any activities outside work. That was one of the reasons why I eventually moved out. I wanted to accomplish things and grow, the companies I interviewed at wanted me to stay 9-5 and be satisfied with their routine. I grew to dislike this attitude and eventually made other plans for myself.
- mvanvoorden 12y agoOn a less-serious side note, this article reminds me a lot of this blog post: http://stuffdutchpeoplelike.com/2012/03/20/not-working/ http://stuffdutchpeoplelike.com/2012/03/20/not-working/
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoThe chart / figures are a bit misleading though; it lists an age range of 15-64. People in the 15-25 age range will generally work part-time (if they work) because they're still in school/college/university. Also, people above 55 (iirc) get 'free' days off (because they're old), I'm not sure if that counts as part-time (since iirc they get paid full-time).f
- timwaagh 12y agowell screw that i'm dutch and i don't get to work part time. would like to though. the new rules are only there 'on paper'. they're not rules as employers can ignore them 'if they have pressing concerns'.
- peter303 12y agoMajor benefits like health and child care are tied to government rather than employment. Therefore you don't have to play games with 2nd careers and minimum hours. Probably a good idea for US to consider.
- teekert 12y agoDutch person here. The only friends I have that work full-time have partners that are at home for the kids. I don't know any couple that both work full-time. Couples that both have a career they want to keep go for 32 hours each and the kids go to daycare for 3 days. I hardly know anyone working full-time among friends my age (lower 30's), even without kids, they just like 3 day weekends. When I applied at ASML they asked me: What if it looks like you will not be able to finish your work within the assigned time, what do you do? I said: I would just work some more, if it doesn't happen very often, not a problem. WRONG. Go to your project leader tell him: "I have time for either this or this, where should I put priority." We do not want overworked people. ASML gave employees about 2 months salary as a bonus some time back, this is on top of a customary 13th month in December.
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoASML is one of the Netherlands' most successful and profitable companies though, and I can imagine they have relatively few but high-skilled employees, especially in the engineering department.
- teekert 12y agoThe large (healthcare) company I work for is the same (minus the bonus). Maybe the little value that is put in hierarchy (my boss has my respect because he is smart, never just because he is my boss). Displays of hierarchy are very badly appreciated here. We appreciate professors that want to be called by their first name. It balances things more perhaps.
- mtrimpe 12y agoCan confirm. There's nothing special about the ASML case. There are a few exceptions in Dutch IT but, unsurprisingly, they are mostly staffed with internationals.
- cscareerbingo 12y agoExpat living in Eindhoven, Netherlands here. For expats having new children the dutch IT very strongly discourage taking 32 hour work weeks. They claim that it makes the employees lose highly skilled migrant status.
- kornakiewicz 12y agoUnfortunately, in the rest of the world "part-time" is not considered as something professional, but it's reserved for cheap labor force (shop assistants, baby-sitters, call-center guys) or for students. Most of "serious" companies won't even think about hiring a professional for 25h.
- iagooar 12y agoReading some of the comments about child care makes me think that we have perverted the way we raise our children. Isn't it plain backwards to send a kid to child care and go to work to pay for it? Unless you are earning an awful lot of money at your job, it doesn't feel right. It just makes so much sense to me to have one of the parents stay at home with the kids, spending most of this beautiful time together. Heck, I want to have kids soon, but first I want to figure out how to earn enough money to maintain my family being the only earner + not working more than 30-32 hours a week. This could mean having a lot less money at the end of month, but it's temporary until the little ones are a bit older.
- gred 12y agoAgree. Just had our first child, and one of us quit our job. It's amazing how much of our budget was being spent on keeping both of us at work. YMMV.
- olau 12y agoSo you don't imagine you being the one home with your children, day in and day out? Life with children is demanding. It's a bit more complex than what you allude to. Not that I'd recommend not having children, I love mine and love taking care of them, but a more realistic view is appropriate, e.g. try googling "toddlers are assholes". :)
- btbuildem 12y agoPeople usually talk about career continuity etc etc.
- dba7dba 12y agoInstead of companies hiring a full time engineer that works 50-60 hours (causing him/her to burn out and quit), how about hiring 2 part timers working 30 hours, allowing more family time. Paying salary for 1 full timer may seem a little lower than 2 part timers initially. But with better family life, I would think you will get better productivity and recover the investment by retaining workers better.
- ptaipale 12y agoThe bean-counters will throw in fixed costs per head. There are facility costs, IT costs (computers probably can not be shared, nor some software licenses), etc. Overheads from support functions (HR etc) are often allocated per head. There are medical insurance etc costs per head. So, bean-counting makes you prefer fewer heads, and some of that cost is not just due to bean-counters, but very real.
- junto 12y agoAnyone else notice that the United Kingdom is listed as "Britain" in that graphic? I don't think Britain is a country.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Anyone else notice that the United Kingdom is listed as "Britain" in that graphic? I don't think Britain is a country. "Britain" is, like "the United Kingdom", a common less-formal name [0] for the nation-state whose full name is the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (and is the source of the usual adjective form associated with that nation-state, "British".) Britain, of course, isn't a "country" as that term is used in the UK, of course; England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland are the countries of the UK. But the use here isn't to identify a country in that sense, but a sovereign state. Better pedants, please. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom : "The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, commonly known as the United Kingdom (UK) or Britain, is a sovereign state in Europe."
- breakingcups 12y agoI'm Dutch and I work part time (32 hours), which was sort of by accident. Since I've started, 5 other people in the company I work for (including the two owners!) have started working 32 hours instead of 40, either to spend more time with their kids or just for themselves. Overall, this makes scheduling work a bit harder for my bosses but other than that there's been nothing but positive results. I'm male by the way.
- czbond 12y agoThis is amazing for me to hear. As an American who is tired of the brainwashed "work at all expenses" cult like mantra here - we've been considering a move to more sane places.