4 ms·
Way too attached to a bit of paint on paper. It was painted after all, to be sold.
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
Way too attached to a bit of paint on paper. It was painted after all, to be sold.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- arfar 12y agoDo you think that art as a commodity is less valuable that "art for arts sake"? Or the fact that an artist (like everyone else in society) needs to get paid to continue to create is a bad thing or cheapens anything they might create?
- tuckerman 12y agoAssuming you are trying to say that artists deserve to get paid for their work, I very much agree. Many people consider themselves to be working in creative professions (many of us on HN do this) and all demand excellent wages for our work. I think a visual artist is deserving of the same!
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNothing cheap about it at all, any more than an engineer selling their skills. If anything, artists are arrogant in claiming creativity as their prerogative, and assigning it value over anyone else's efforts.
- dogecoinbase 12y agoWay too attached to a bit of paint on paper. Is there a name for the rhetorical device where one tries to devalue something by referring to it in this technically-correct-debasing kind of way? I feel like I'm seeing it more and more often on HN and elsewhere. It's some kind of anti-intellectualism but I feel like it must be more specific.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mikekchar 12y agoPeople have opinions. Sometimes, missing the opportunity to understand the other side of the equation, they attach an oversimplified label in order to make their opinion seem obvious and correct. Usually, though, it is an honest expression of their opinion however much they are ignoring the other opinions around them. As you correctly point out, it is very common. You can choose to break the cycle, if you like. Acknowledging the other person's opinion as valid is the first step. After that, you may or may not want to encourage them to expand their view. However, if you think that the other person is unable to understand this point you may choose not to waste your time. I suspect that you could find a simplified label to describe the comment of the parent post, but perhaps it would be better to consider their opinion as valid and move on.
- xefer 12y agoMeiosis http://rhetoric.byu.edu/figures/M/meiosis.htm http://rhetoric.byu.edu/figures/M/meiosis.htm
- noonespecial 12y agoI've gone s far as to call it the "yellow metal" fallacy. (ie gold) Its all just matter in the end, but sometimes there's value in how its arranged. Ignoring that is stupid.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNo, its called intellectual honesty, or integrity. To subscribe to someone else's value system and order your life according to their views is stupid.
- kingmanaz 12y agoReductionism, or substituting the part for the whole.
- InclinedPlane 12y agoWay too attached to your body, your intellect, your values, your hobbies. You were created to replicate DNA, after all.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoAh. No. See, the painter got to paint it and sell it, presumably to a private individual, whereupon it was not seen for decades. This was ok. Now that private individual seeks to resell it, exactly as the artist did originally, and is marked a philistine and evil person, who 'disgusts' the OP. I called double standard. Clear?