7 ms·
White House Names Dr. Ed Felten as Deputy U.S. Chief Technology Officer
- JoshTriplett 12y agoThis is a refreshing dose of sanity, considering his technology background and history (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Felten https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Felten). I look forward to seeing what he can accomplish in this position.
- gcb0 12y agohe sued a drm company that played the dmca card on him. will love (not) to see him backing up things like dmca now...
- JacobEdelman 12y agoI've met him a few times and I've seen him speak. He definitely seems to be the kind of change we need.
- xnull6guest 12y agoCan you clarify what changes you would expect Felten to bring into the government? I'm a little frustrated by the lack of specifics in both the article, the Wiki page, and these comments. What about his technology background and history make him a particularly viable candidate - and what changes will we expect him to bring to bear from his background?
- JoshTriplett 12y agoHe's pro-technology, pro-privacy, anti-DRM, anti-DMCA, etc. I'm hoping that he will use this role to make the government a little less technophobic, a little less inclined to use laws to prop up companies that can't cope with new technologies, and a little less inclined towards mass spying and data collection. On the other hand, I have no idea how much influence this role actually has; we'll see how it goes over the next few years.
- sukilot 12y agoDRM is technology. Don't confuse "anti-tech" with "pro-entrenched wealthy interests"
- JoshTriplett 12y agoDRM is a technology that restricts the invention of future technologies. DRM enumerates what you can do with data, which by design restricts future possibilities as well as present ones. One of the key features of non-DRMed data is that it can be used in novel ways that its original authors never thought of. On balance, I feel comfortable classifying DRM systems as "anti-technology": they prevent the further advancement of technology past the vision of what the authors of the DRM system could think of and deigned to allow. More importantly, laws and policies that enforce DRM are anti-technology. But in any case, a clarification then: against DRM enforced by law, such as via the DMCA, or enshrined into "standards" that are then used by governmental entities. DRM enforced solely by technology, without the backing of laws like the DMCA, is not necessarily a governmental issue, though it's still something to fight against.
- staunch 12y agoI bet he'd make a great president himself.
- themeek 12y agoI am able to access some of his syllabi for his law and policy classes from his homepage (for example, here's a syllabus for Digital Surveillance [1]), but can't find very particularly much on his politics. Does anyone know where he stands on public policy with regard to IP law, civil law, domestic surveillance and domestic propaganda? [1] https://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall13/cos597G/ https://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall13/cos597G/
- dadrian 12y agoEd largely opposes mass surveillance, etc. See some of his posts on Freedom to Tinker: https://freedom-to-tinker.com/blog/author/felten/ https://freedom-to-tinker.com/blog/author/felten/
- colechristensen 12y agoHe was a board member of the EFF, which should tell you enough.
- themeek 12y agoBeing a board member of the EFF isn't enough for me - I like to understand specifics and don't trust the EFF sheerly on invocation of their name.
- niels_olson 12y agoAnd since you're so vociferous, I'm sure you'll do some good research and write it up for us, right? :)
- themeek 12y agoIt all depends on time, though it's unlikely I'll do a dossier on the EFF unless something prompts it. I will say broadly that their coverage of information sharing, surveillance law, and intellectual property is rounded down to their specific issues and narrow perspective - and these issues aren't necessarily one-for-one mappings to "what's best for the internet/civility". One example that comes to mind was their coverage of the recent Obama Administration Executive Order 13694 [1][2] where they dropped the international purpose and nature of the order entirely, as if the sanctions weren't directed towards, and enforced by law, at actors in China and Russia (and Iran and smaller players) overseas. Following Snowden - who truly did show that the NSA was surveiling hundreds of millions of Americans - the EFF's speculatory, alarmist and misleading coverage of national cybersecurity and civil rights confused and angered a confused and angry group of people we would rather have engaged in deliberate and reasonable debate. Namely, despite how different in kind, scope, purpose and method EO 13694 is, the EFF reported on it with the tone of the Snowden disclosures and its audience associated the two. I have spoken, too, with the EFF - and was disappointed both by their their inability to use PGP (even after suggesting it to others) and the way they engaged with the material I provided them. [I sent them evidence of a backdoor in popular software and an analysis of a possible convenient backdoor location for a popular hardware brand; they quietly acknowledged these reports but AFAICT did nothing with them - as a comparison when I sent similar material, using PGP, to cryptome they were immediately published.] I should not have been so disappointed by what they did with the materials I sent to them: I did not understand at the time the scope of the EFF - that even their published matrix of trustworthy communication software was a stretch of their operating scope. So this isn't to rag so very much on the EFF. I think they have a role in advocacy and journalism and the legal landscape. I'm just not willing to invest my full and unquestioning faith in the reports of any interest group - for even those with good intentions are not infallible. [Anecdotes only today, I'm afraid. :)] [1] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/04/whitehouses-new-executive-order-cyber-crime-unfortunately-no-joke https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/04/whitehouses-new-execut... [2] https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/04/01/executive-order-blocking-property-certain-persons-engaging-significant-m https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/04/01/execu...
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoI never understood some of these high level appointments when its comes to technology. What does this role really do? It seems borderline ceremonial, like the King's wizard or somesuch.
- LordKano 12y agoIt's having someone who is knowledgeable about a subject in place to translate the President's position into one that would make sense to other knowledgeable people.
- jkestner 12y agoThat wouldn't be terribly useful to us. I'd rather it work in the other direction - translating technical knowledge into something the president can use to shape better policy. Once our government loses its technical ignorance, we won't have to use Hanlon's Razor to excuse them.
- LordKano 12y agoI agree, that would be more useful and I too would rather it was the other way 'round but unfortunately, that's not how things work. The people who have the political cloud and the numbers to drive policy aren't necessarily the ones with the best understanding of the issues.
- the8472 12y ago> political cloud cloud-based politics? Not yet. It's still clout-based ;)
- mhurron 12y ago> What does this role really do? Act as a stepping stone to bigger positions in the private sector.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MrZongle2 12y agoI find it difficult to not view such appointments with a great deal of cynicism. We are supposedly six years into an administration that promised change from what came before, but seems determined to maintain the status quo on many fronts.
- shit_parade2 12y agoI fully agree, if anything it impinges on the reputation of anyone who willing works with the lying murders in the White House.
- dude_abides 12y agotime to go long on bitcoin!
- drcode 12y agoGiven how things have been going lately, I'll just be happy if all the recent good news doesn't lead to another price crash.
- jonstokes 12y agoI followed and covered Ed's career over the years at Ars, and he's a great technologist and one of the Good Guys. EFF board member, anti-DRM activist, one of those sounding the alarm on e-voting and mass surveillance. In other words, he's opposed to just about everything that Obama seems to stand for in practice (disregarding the president's rhetoric on these issues). So I have to wonder, is this one of those "keep your enemies closer" things? Anyway, congrats(?) to Prof. Felten. Here's to hoping he can make a difference.
- wsxcde 12y agoWell, he was named CTO of the FTC back in 2010, so it seems he has a good relationship with the Obama administration.
- csoghoian 12y agoThe Federal Trade Commission is an independent agency. They don't take orders from the President. (I know, because I worked there for a year)
- dmix 12y ago> he's opposed to just about everything that Obama seems to stand for in practice If the gov had to excluded Tech people who didn't fit this profile they wouldn't be able to find anyone left to recruit.
- shit_parade2 12y agoRidiculous, he isn't a 'good' guy, he works for someone who tortures and murders innocents without qualms or cares. Down vote the truth.
- xnull2guest 12y agoWhat I think that the OP meant was that for the purposes of his role, he is an advocate for the types of civil initiatives supported by most of the HN crowd. In some sense every American that has benefited from torture, assassination, coup, neocolonialization, murder, and enslavement by America's administrations and corporations aren't 'good' people.
- mrb 12y agoFYI this news is creating excitement in the Bitcoin community because Dr. Ed Felten is a notable Bitcoin researcher and advocate: http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-researcher-ed-felten-white-house/ http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-researcher-ed-felten-white-h...