6 ms·
There may be room for debate, but is there time for debate? Is there a plausible case that we cannot afford to wait?
by tome 17y ago
There may be room for debate, but is there time for debate?
Is there a plausible case that we cannot afford to wait?
- tome 17y agoThis is a valid question I think. "An Inconvenient Truth" came out three years ago. In that time it may or may not have come to light whether or not we can afford to wait. I think it's likely that it in fact has. If you disagree please reply instead of downmodding.
- fnid 17y agoI think if the earth has actually been cooling since 1980, that's pretty good evidence we can wait. It's actually evidence that it isn't human action causing the climate change, so we can forget about trying to change whatever behaviors it is of ours that are causing it and focus on the real problem: How do we adapt to a warmer planet? That is the real problem with the whole debate. It is centered on "humans have cause climate change." If the reality is that the sun is causing climate change or, "Climate change happens in cycles," which it has since the earth formed, then the response and the path forward is very different from the ones currently proposed. EDIT: You know, in a way, saying climate change is human responsibility is enabling us to avoid doing what we have to do now. For example, if sea levels will continue to rise for 100 years, we should stop all new coastal development. Saying humans can stop the warming and lower the sea levels allows us to keep building on the coasts. Essentially, saying, "In the future, we can stop climate change" allows us to do nothing in the present. Imagine the difference if we knew it was not caused by humans or in fact, there is nothing we can do, the planet will continue to get hotter for 100 years, then we start building cities underground, moving civilization to the poles of the earth, inventing more heat tolerant crops, better local climate control, etc.
- tome 17y agoYour point in your EDIT about being unaware or unaccepting of (potential) real ways to mitigate climate is an excellent one, thanks!
- antipaganda 17y agoHow can the Earth have been cooling since 1980 if most of the 10 hottest years in recorded history were in the 2000s?
- crystalis 17y agoThis is a reasonable question to ask. If global warming is "wrong" but the accepted answer, pollution heavy businesses go through some inefficiencies and there's a smaller amount of pollution production. If global warming is "right", but not accepted as something that requires response, potential existential crises ensue. It seems like betting on a Jack-high hand with your life on the line.
- dantheman 17y agoBut there a lot of decisions like that. 1. If we don't invest in SETI aliens could come and wipe us out; seems like a bad bet to make we should fund set at 10000% 2. We need better protection from asteroids one could wipe us out; we need to tax every human being @ 80 % to build a giant defense network. 3. There could be a disease that wipes out the human race we need to increase the amount of spending on health care... etc etc Looking at the extreme edges with out an idea of probabilities is an easy way to get confused.
- crystalis 17y agoI'd say you've gone wrong twice, here. You have included problems (with unusual "solutions") with probabilities on hugely different magnitudes on the same list, and presumed that every problem is equally soluble. Global warming has a reasonable probability distribution and a very feasible solution. Compare that to hostile aliens with the ability to travel from the far reaches of undetectability to Earth- the technology gulf would be impossible to overcome.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoPascal asked a similar question: If the bible is wrong but the accepted answer, you lose a finite amount of hedonic pleasure in the near term and there are some short term benefits (smaller amount of killing/stealing/coveting). If the bible is right, but not accepted, you will burn in hell for all eternity.
- tome 17y agoSure, but that's rather over-exaggerating to make a cheap point. Every business asks a similar question every day. "If I decide to do A, I might make $B dollars or lose $C dollars. Is this a wise thing to do?" We tend to think that Pascal's cost benefit analysis was flawed. That doesn't mean we should drop the principle altogether!
- BearOfNH 17y agoIs there a plausible case that we cannot afford to wait? If it isn't caused by humans it's unlikely to be fixable by humans.
- tensor 17y agoI'm not sure why you'd assume that. Humans can indeed make big changes to the environment. Typically these are negative, clearing of huge areas of forest, the air/smog in China. But perhaps there are positive examples too. And if not, well, we really wouldn't know unless we try. Do we even know enough about climate to know what to try and do though? Its not something I've spent a huge amount of time researching.