8 ms·
CloudFlare “Interview Questions”
- agonzalezro 12y agoI've mentioned it on the blogpost but: Do you have some metrics about the success of your candidates replying to those questions?
- ajkjk 12y agoThese are not actually interview questions.
- agonzalezro 12y agoWell, I know that there are "interview questions", but they are trying to show us the kind of knowledge that is needed to join a Company as Cloudfare so I am pretty sure that some of those are going to be questions in some point of their interview process. I just wanted to know that in case that the questions are formulated that way, what's the ratio of people that can successfully answer those.
- biot 12y agomu out of zero people asked successfully answered.
- ajkjk 12y agoThe article says: "For quite some time we've been grilling our candidates about dirty corners of TCP/IP stack. Every engineer here must prove his/her comprehensive understanding of the full network stack. For example: what are the differences in checksumming algorithms between IPv4 and IPv6 stacks? I'm joking of course, but in the spirit of the old TCP/IP pub game I want to share some of the amusing TCP/IP quirks I've bumped into over the last few months while working on CloudFlare's automatic attack mitigation systems." That is, these are not real interview questions. They are trivia questions. I doubt most engineers even at Cloudflare can answer these without research.
- dominotw 12y agoCan't someone learn these in a couple of months. Why does a candidate have to know all these already?
- Rapzid 12y agoDays. The article pretty quickly diverts away from the subject of interview questions. "The goal is to encourage our readers to review the dusty RFCs, get interested in the inner workings of the network stack and generally spread the knowledge about the protocols we rely on so much."
- addandsubtract 12y agoThe subject was to mock interview questions in interviews, as depicted by the use of quotes around "interview questions". The article then goes on to peak the interest of the reader about TCP/IP quirks that cloudflare has faced over the past couple of months; i.e. real work challenges that potential employees should be able to research and answer.
- mankyd 12y agoFor quite some time we've been grilling our candidates about dirty corners of TCP/IP stack. [...] I'm joking of course, [...] They don't need know these. These aren't interview questions, they're just TCP/UDP trivia.
- JustSomeNobody 12y agoThe article was joking about the interview questions. But let's say they weren't. I'd answer your question thusly: Interest. If someone interviewed and had an answer to most of these questions, it would at least show that they had an interest in the material and weren't just looking for a job.
- kocsenc 12y agoSo, for those interested in learning could we possibly have a quick short answer for each one of them? K
- BinaryIdiot 12y agoThis is what I was looking forward to but never saw a list of answers.
- tptacek 12y agoWhat specific questions are you finding hard to look up? (Some of them are easy to find, some aren't.)
- BinaryIdiot 12y agoSince this is essentially a list of trivia / interesting questions I was hoping for a list of answers just as easy to consume. I was able to look-up most of the ones I cheery-picked.
- toothbrush 12y agocheery-picked That made me smile. Mental image: cherry-picking after a few pints.
- brlewis 12y ago2/3 top-level comments are confusion re. the title. Can we have a different title for HN in this case? EDIT: Title as I write this: CloudFlare “Interview Questions”
- outworlder 12y agoThe quotes are there for a reason.
- brlewis 12y agoI understood the quote marks myself, but when you look at many of the comments here, it's obvious many didn't. So the reason failed.
- spoiler 12y agoIt's etiquette to use the original title that you're linking to, unless it's a bit older (then you can include a year), or if the original title is too ambiguous. I think it's reasonable as it is right now.
- brlewis 12y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html The guidelines allow for changing a misleading title, even if it was unintentionally misleading. From the comments here, clearly many were misled.
- snooc 12y agoNice blog post CloudFlare SEO team!
- jgrahamc 12y agoEvery single member of the CloudFlare team is part of our marketing effort.
- guava 12y agoLet's collaboratively collect the answers to these (trivia!) questions: http://collabedit.com/rsjy8 http://collabedit.com/rsjy8
- squeed 12y agoThanks, this is fun!
- guava 12y ago(Saving current progress in case someone abuses the page again: http://pastie.org/pastes/10182802/text http://pastie.org/pastes/10182802/text [16:08 Monday, May 11, 2015 UTC].)
- singlow 12y agoAnd they did!
- danappelxx 12y agoHey look, a dickbutt!
- zorked 12y agoEverybody is taking these questions too seriously. These are not interview questions, and these are quite fun actually - I know the answer to a few of them (not because I know RFCs by heart but because I had to deal with them in the past), and the others are just intriguing enough that I may actually go look for answers.
- _pmf_ 12y ago> These are not interview questions These should become interview questions when somebody declares himself/herself an expert in TCP/IP.
- tptacek 12y agoIf the purpose of an interview is to deflate claims people make about their expertise, sure. That's not a productive goal for an interview, though.
- borski 12y agoIs it not? Hypothetically, is it not worth knowing that someone has exaggerated or lied about their skills in something? That would seem to be useful information in an interview; i.e. can someone say "I don't know" or will they make up something instead.
- tptacek 12y agoIt can be, but I think the idea that it should be is probably the biggest misconception in hiring, and the biggest impediment most startups have to effectively hiring engineers. Consider: there's a difference, perhaps subtle, between "deflating claimed expertise" and "assessing ability to perform a job".
- autotune 12y ago> "deflating claimed expertise" and "assessing ability to perform a job". This is a very important point, and also why I never claim to know anything I can't prove (speaking as a Linux Admin, not even developer). Everything in my resume points back to the github so whoever is interviewing can know exactly how far I've studied or had experience with a specific subject, and acts as a reference point for the job of course. Also lets me know which companies to avoid if they just care about random trivia questions rather than how much demonstrable value you can offer them.
- digital-rubber 12y agowonder why this one is missing, "Do reply to people that we are responsible in anyway for being a passthrough for cloudflare proxied/hosted services?" no we always pretend we are not part of the chain and refuse to deal with complaints.
- joeblau 12y agoAh... this bring back memories! When I was doing dev ops I had to know a lot more about the nitty gritty details of networking. Still know a few of these, but most have been forgotten.
- Kenji 12y ago"For quite some time we've been grilling our candidates about dirty corners of TCP/IP stack. Every engineer here must prove his/her comprehensive understanding of the full network stack. For example: what are the differences in checksumming algorithms between IPv4 and IPv6 stacks?" I read that and was blown away, uttering "Bloody hell." I would have never known that from the top of my head. Good joke, well played, sir.
- mauricemir 12y agoWhat you really need to know the dirty little secrets of the various implementations of the stacks and the short cuts (or blatant ignoring of standards). My Boss at BT could do this from a x.400 packet trace and point to the offending dword and say that is XXX's POS stack. There is also the story of a guy (at BT Labs) who took the CCIE and only scored 98% he then wrote a personal letter to John Chambers explaining why he was right and Cisco was not. ... Turns out he was one of the 3 inventors of Ethernet
- Achshar 12y agoDo you have some link where I can read more about it? I googled but nothing came up. The part about the CCIE.
- mauricemir 12y agoIt was told to me by coworker at BT
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 12y agoI think TCP SYN segments have always been able to carry payloads; they're not delivered until the 3WH completes. A fun set of trivia questions involves inconsistent retransmission: in out-of-order delivery, with some data buffered --- IP fragments or TCP segments --- what happens when the packet that allows reassembly to proceed (a) overlaps data already sent and (b) that overlapping data isn't the same as what was already buffered? (When we wrote the IDS paper, Vern Paxson told us he'd been observing this happening in the wild, which blows my mind). Another fun set of interview questions pertains to how you'd design the fastest possible "traceroute" program. You can do better than parallelizing/pipelining. :) I used to like asking people what the utility of discard, chargen, and echo were.
- throwawaykf05 12y agoMy first reaction to the "fastest traceroute" question would be, is this a trick question? This is because many routers rate-limit the number of ICMP packets they forward. Causing a lot of ICMP replies could easily exceed this limit and result in missing hops. This requires being deliberately slow. A lot of the early Internet measurement studies had to deal with these problems, though ideally a single traceroute is less likely to trigger this behavior. However, your hint indicates that there's something other than inducing a number of TTL exceeded packets. Can't verify as I'm on mobile, but are you thinking of the TCP Record Route option?
- nitinics 12y agoI'd think sending multiple packets (parallelism) with varying TTLs (1,2,3..n) without waiting for responses from each hops to increment the TTL, would probably give us faster traceroute. n being the number of hops you "expect" the destination subnet to be.
- dedalus 12y ago>13) Can a SYN packet have a payload? (hint: new RFC proposals) Hint is ok but RFC 1379 and RFC 1644 predate your hint. I have personally seen this happen as I implemented it :-)
- iMark 12y agoI start at CloudFlare in a week. I was fortunate in that I came via a recommendation. Still, for whatever it's worth, I was genuinely impressed with everyone I spoke with throughout the chain.
- Raed667 12y agoI do CS (software mainly) graduating next year And I only know a couple of these .. Should I be worried ?
- lmm 12y agoNo. If you can't figure them out from reading the relevant RFCs, then maybe (reading specs is a vital skill), but this is absolutely not stuff that's worth memorizing (at least for most CS jobs).
- shampine 12y agoI think it's just confirmation that we can't know everything and there is always room to learn more.
- jerf 12y agoNo. Even if you applied to a new job that related to all this it would generally be understood that as a new grad you're not going to know this stuff, and either A: the job would never have been posted in such a way as to lead you to apply or B: they understand there's going to be on-the-job training. That said, if you're specifically applying to CloudFlare, you just got handed a great study sheet to differentiate yourself very handily from your peers. You'd think that "everyone" looks for this sort of thing, but given the ongoing streams of reports of "people who fail FizzBuzz", no, seriously, few people look at this sort of thing before interviews!
- xorcist 12y agoWhy should you? These are tricky domain specific questions that a network engineer with intimate knowledge of TCP/IP could answer some of. I certainly wouldn't expect a fresh CS graduate to know these things unless you did a lot of work in that area for some reason.
- kabdib 12y agoNo. And if you run into a company where they do ask these questions (and others like them) and take them seriously, then try really hard not to work there because it will probably suck.
- 12y ago
- jtchang 12y agoI love these questions. I wouldn't expect any interviewee to know all of them. But I'd expect them to be able to talk intelligently about some of them. For a software candidate a simple question like "tell me what you know about TCP/IP" is a great start to just probe what they know about networking.
- sigjuice 12y agoHere is how I did a TCP simultaneous open over the loopback interface. http://stackoverflow.com/a/2263853/78720 http://stackoverflow.com/a/2263853/78720
- majke 12y agoWow, this is awesome. So it works!
- Animats 12y agoCloudflare needs people who understand this, since they're a man-in-the-middle security hole/backdoor. Note that they're not asking questions about security. This shows their priorities.
- jgrahamc 12y agoOh, please.
- Animats 12y agoCloudflare reserves the right to add adware and spyware to your pages as they pass through Cloudflare's MITM center. ("CloudFlare may: ... Add script to your pages to, for example, add services, Apps, or perform additional performance tracking."[1]) [1] https://www.cloudflare.com/terms https://www.cloudflare.com/terms
- jaak 12y agoYou should have continued: CloudFlare will make it clear whenever a feature will modify your content and, whenever possible, provide you a mechanism to allow you to disable the feature.
- Animats 12y agoWhen privacy and security require an opt-out, you can be sure the vendor plans to violate them. Their "free HTTPS everywhere" plan has to be monetized somehow.
- bjterry 12y agoThis is almost unrelated to the post, but the question on the MD5 checksum was the inspiration. It seems like we could have a DoS mitigation strategy with a protocol extension that required the packets to be checksummed with a key stretching algorithm (similar to bcrypt). The worse the DoS got, the higher the number of iterations that could be required. If routers at the network edge could verify the checksums somehow then the traffic would be dropped at distributed nodes rather than at a central node. Ideally you'd want something easy to verify but hard to calculate for the client. Of course, I know nothing about DoS attacks, so this is probably trivially wrong in some way.
- iDemonix 12y agoI've always thought a job at CloudFlare would be awesome, so much so that I took their list of requirements for a SRE role and set them as goals to work towards. After reading this list of questions, however, maybe I should lower my expectations, I could barely answer 25%.