6 ms·
A machine that speeds up evolution is revolutionizing genome design
- ludamad 12y agoCan someone more in the field tell me if this is exciting to them, and to what degree?
- dnautics 12y agoIt's a pain. There are better continuous evolution systems on the horizon. Not many people use this. It's hard to select for anything besides growth.
- unemouette 12y agoEvolution is a complete scam
- LunaSea 12y agoWhat are you proposing then ?
- axefrog 12y agoTake a moment and watch this. Disbelief in evolution usually only happens when one doesn't really understand the field and would prefer to try and explain everything with religion, in which case you may as well try and explain thunder as the sound the gods' bellies make when rumbling. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIEoO5KdPvg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIEoO5KdPvg
- auganov 12y agoI just watched it. I'm pretty ignorant in terms of biology and never really gave it much thought. The video you posted presents a good case that all living beings are related in some way and only hints at evolution by briefly talking about different fossils at different times suggesting some transitions over time. So as a person that has no opinion I'd rather have the actual transitions explained and proved in depth.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoOne way of thinking about it is mathematical, and is the nearest you will get to a positive proof. If you have systems which can propagate copies of themselves imperfectly and that have a varying environment to contend with that has effects on their ability to propagate, then the subsequent copies of those systems will undergo an evolution of forms with a selection bias. Mathematically you can demonstrate this pretty conclusively. Then all you really need to do is demonstrate that there are systems in the physical world that meet the set of criteria required for evolution to occur and you can then be pretty sure that evolution is occurring.
- unemouette 12y ago"Evolution is a fairytale for grown-ups. It is useless" Pierre P. Grasse, leading french biologist "Scientists who go about teaching that evolution is a fact of life are great con men, and the story they are telling may be the greatest hoax ever. In explaining evolution we do not have one iota of fact." T.N. Tahmisian, physiologist for the Atomic Energy Commission "Evolution is baseless and quite incredible." Ambrose Flemming, president, British Association for Advancement of Science I can found hundreds other quotes like these made by famous scientists. Beneficial mutations do not exist, therefore, evolution of the living is unproved. There is no species that could stand as an intermediate between man and anything else. There is in nature zero intermediate state between bird's feathers and anything else. Evolutionnists have no clue how to explain the origin of the cetacean. Evolution is a complete hoax, it has not been thrown to the trash can just because of the alternative theory that is left if evolution disappears. And you know what it is.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoit has not been thrown to the trash can just because of the alternative theory that is left if evolution disappears. And you know what it is. Well, given you are invoking the support of Pierre P. Grasse, I guess you mean the evolution of forms through heritability of acquired characteristics.
- 12y ago
- robbiep 12y agoFor those not in the know George Church and his team have been at the forefront of biochemical research and development of novel techniques for well over a decade. This concept, like so many other techniques developed by that lab, is very impressive. The last major contribution I was on the cutting edge of (back in 2008) was the ability to predict and design proteins with totally different amino acid sequences that performed the same function biologically, which was revolutionary as it showed not only that you can replace almost every amino acid in a protein with a different residue and be biologically equivalent. It also proved that it was not the actual amino acid sequence that performed the function but the type of residue (hydrophobic, hydrophillic, acidic, basic, large or small). Of course, you can't overcome a well placed disulphide bond but the ability to do this basically nullified any possibility that a company or organisation could patent a particular protein, as you could simply replace almost the entire sequence of that protein and still have the same functionality. I'm sure I have missed numerous other advances over the past 7 years as well. Some cool stuff coming out of that lab. Edit: it looks like this was from 2009 so not as cutting edge as I thought
- gwern 12y agoIt may be from 2009, but it looks like there's been more work than I expected using the MAGE machine going by Google Scholar cites of their paper "Programming cells by multiplex genome engineering and accelerated evolution": http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=12846716603863206939&as_sdt=20000005&sciodt=0,21 http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=12846716603863206939...
- dschiptsov 12y agoOk, the speed up is basically much quicker shuffling, but how do they test the results?)
- smoyer 12y agoI wonder how the "life" this machine creates is regulated. In Eric K. Drexler's book "Engines of Creation", he warns that the rise of self-assembly and nanotechnology needs to be carefully controlled so that we don't end up disassembling the whole world into "gray goo". It seems to me that a shotgun approach to evolving organisms could be as dangerous.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoIt seems to me that a shotgun approach to evolving organisms could be as dangerous. Viruses are well ahead of us in that. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endogenous_retrovirus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endogenous_retrovirus
- wcoenen 12y agoIs glowingplant.com using something like this "MAGE" device? They seem to be doing well at improving luminosity through directed evolution, as can be seen in the graph in the December [1] update. According to their last update[2], they've increased the automation since then. [1] http://blog.glowingplant.com/post/105558826472/happy-holidays-glowing-plant-december-update http://blog.glowingplant.com/post/105558826472/happy-holiday... [2] http://blog.glowingplant.com/post/118481662132/glowing-plant-may-update http://blog.glowingplant.com/post/118481662132/glowing-plant...