3 ms·
I have an issue with reasoning about what system you're gonna use to be productive based on ideology-based values. I've used Windows, Linux and OS X to develop
by piva00 12y ago
I have an issue with reasoning about what system you're gonna use to be productive based on ideology-based values.
I've used Windows, Linux and OS X to develop, mostly of the environment I'm responsible for is Linux (and some Mac dev machines our team uses). In my opinion I'm really most productive in OS X, I don't have to be aware of weird glitches when using distro Y in hardware Z nor do I need to configure anything to work in my Macs, they just works and that's what I really want from a workstation.
I don't feel locked-down, I have a lot of UNIX tools to leverage myself while having support from a very sane and invisible UI experience.
Really, the time when Mavericks came and fucked up ntpd and our machines started to have weird glitches with HTTPS and other time-based authentications I got really angry. But then I remembered when I had to fiddle with Xorg or run a laptop without sound for months under CentOS or Mint or any other of the dozen of distros I've tried to use.
I love to tinker with computers, that's why I chose this career, but when you get older you begin to really praise when work-stuff "just works", you let the tinkering to stuff which you want to play with.
So yeah, I know there are some good arguments to use Linux vs OS X but ideology is not one I'm really fond of.
- ekianjo 12y ago> So yeah, I know there are some good arguments to use Linux vs OS X but ideology is not one I'm really fond of. Yet this is exactly where ideology matters. If Apple as a corporation decides to make OSX worse than it is, later on, you will have no choice but to follow, if you stay on Mac hardware. Linux is the only option that gives you freedom to choose your tools, your distribution that fits you best, and change if needed.
- PebblesHD 12y ago> Linux is the only option that gives you the freedom to... And exactly how is Apple or the use of a Macbook restricting your toolset in every way. OSX is UNIX compliant and will run damn near any tool a generix Linux distro can, with the added bonus that it wont take a thousand years to configure and maintain. Add to that the ability for enterprise to use a policy server and even domain logons with limited hassle and it forms quite a reasonable platform for development. Linux is a perfectly usable development OS, but OSX and Windows are just as capable given the same amount of configuration.
- dman 12y agoI have to disagree about this. As a development environment both Windows and OSX are noticeably more broken out of the box as compared to Linux / FreeBSD. Neither comes with a package manager and you have to go through a song and dance to get a compiler / debugger / profiler toolchain setup on either platform. You cant dump out the list of installed packages from your prior machine and use it as a recipe to get your new machine setup. On a linux box, I can provision a new machine and have it behave exactly as I want in under 10 minutes. Getting nfs setup with good transfer speeds was an exercise in frustration on Yosemite (Ultimately I gave up, even on an ethernet connection I cannot coax my macbook pro to do > 2 Mbps nfs transfers). On Windows I had to buy an enterprise version for NFS share support.
- duncan_bayne 12y agoWhile working on one contract, I sat next to two devs who spent at least a day trying to get Ruby 2.0 (back when it was new) and associated libraries compiling and running properly on OSX. I don't know how long they spent, they were still at it when I left that evening. All my Linux (Mint) setup is in a bunch of scripts that live in Git. I can have a fully configured dev machine running in under an hour, starting from a fresh OS installation.
- stephenr 12y agoHow long did those scripts take you to write? With similar scripts an OS X machine could also be configured.
- duncan_bayne 12y ago"How long did those scripts take you to write?" Quite a while; I haven't totalled up the hours but I'd guess several days at least. The amount of time it's saved me must surely exceed that. I've installed a good number of machines (personal, work, hacking etc.) from scratch using them. I generally don't bother upgrading OSs, either; I just perform a fresh installation, run the scripts, and tweak whatever is broken in the latest release. History is here: https://github.com/duncan-bayne/mint-setup/branches https://github.com/duncan-bayne/mint-setup/branches "With similar scripts an OS X machine could also be configured." Not in my experience. I did spend - along with a team of very smart OSX-based developers - quite some time trying and failing to achieve a similar level of automation on OSX. We got tantalisingly close at times, but never achieved anything like the level of control possible on Linux or BSD. Edited: oh, and having those scripts on hand can be really useful when attempting to provision ancient hardware. See e.g. https://github.com/duncan-bayne/g3-setup/wiki https://github.com/duncan-bayne/g3-setup/wiki
- duncan_bayne 12y ago"I have an issue with reasoning about what system you're gonna use to be productive based on ideology-based values." I have had literally years of experience trying to standardise OSX across a range of pairing workstations, and the experience was sufficiently bad to: a) put me off OSX entirely as a 'serious' OS b) motivate me to develop a Vagrant-based dev system that could be shared across OSX hosts, and used via SSH w/ X forwarding I demonstrated the solution to a local Ruby on Rails meetup, where it was fairly well received despite the vast majority of the audience being Apple users and, in many cases, advocates. I wasn't trying to make an ideological argument there. Leaving the ideology aside: been there, done that, never again. "So yeah, I know there are some good arguments to use Linux vs OS X but ideology is not one I'm really fond of." In terms of ideology, look at say kernel extensions. These days, you have to have permission from Apple to sign kernel extensions such that you can install them on your own machine. Not only does this mean that OSX is broken as a machine for serious work (i.e. stuff beyond running your latest Rails project), it's a clear example of how important ideology actually is. Ideology is important. Sooner or later, it makes or breaks your project in ways you'd never expect. (The same is true of teams, companies and entire countries).