4 ms·
EDIT: This got down-modded, and I'm not sure why. You may disagree with it, but I think it adds value to the discussion. I've touched it lightly to make it sl
by RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago
EDIT: This got down-modded, and I'm not sure why. You may disagree with it, but I think it adds value to the discussion. I've touched it lightly to make it slightly more generic, but I still stand by what it says. Teaching is hard, math is hard, someone who can do both can make more money elsewhere. If you disagree I'd be delighted to hear your case and thoughts.
It sounds a lot to me from this and other contributions you've made about math that you, like many others, have been damaged by some really bad teaching. Using these techniques properly gives the child/student powerful tools for analysing situations they haven't seen before. Teaching rote techniques doesn't - of itself - provide that power and flexibility.
Having said that, these "illustratory" techniques are often taught appallingly by well-meaning and gifted teachers who themselves have learned by rote what to do, but don't themselves have any real understanding of the math underneath. We need teachers who are gifted teachers, but who understand the underlying principles.
Unfortunately, those gifted in math are rarely gifted in teached, especially teaching children. Add to that the fact that they could earn more respect, reputation and money using the math, and what we have is a continuing disaster in math education.
I have no answers.