4 ms·
Everything you wrote is reasonable except this: > To put in perspective, you should only do a test if you have good a priori chance of having a positive. Ther
by jessriedel 12y ago
Everything you wrote is reasonable except this:
> To put in perspective, you should only do a test if you have good a priori chance of having a positive.
There are several reasons to run a test that yields a small posteriori probability even after a positive result (i.e., a test such that most positives are false positive). The most common reason is that this test is much cheaper (or has fewer risks, etc.) than a more accurate test. The protocol, then, is to run the cheap test and then run the expensive test if you get an initial positive result. The only time you end up believing it's a true positive is when the expensive test returns positive.
This is fairly common in medicine, for example the syphilis test: http://www.webmd.com/sexual-conditions/syphilis-tests http://www.webmd.com/sexual-conditions/syphilis-tests
- valleyer 12y agoOr, if the false positives are probabilistically independent, just run the same test again. If your test gives back 1% false positives, running it twice gets you down to .01%, three times gives you one in a million.
- jessriedel 12y agoUnfortunately, this is essentially never the case. The reason is that if the outcomes were probabilistically independent, then you would just declare a standard protocol of always running the test N times, and call that the test. It's safe to assume that such trivial optimizations have already been done for medical tests.
- valleyer 12y agoFair enough. What is an example of a test that has false positives that are not independent (and why)? Curious now.
- jessriedel 12y agoThe common syphilis test looks for antibodies that are produced in response to the bacteria. However, the body may produce those antibodies (on a continuing basis) for other reasons. If you find these antibodies the first time in a given person, you'll keep finding them when you re-test.