4 ms·
They are not, in fact 'objectively' better, because the degree to which you prioritize each of those things differs based on each person's values. Take welfare,
by TulliusCicero 12y ago
They are not, in fact 'objectively' better, because the degree to which you prioritize each of those things differs based on each person's values. Take welfare, for instance. Social welfare programs help the vulnerable, and undoubtedly some non-zero percentage of people are taking advantage of said programs wrongly. In the US, people who are liberal are more interested in the former, and people who are conservative are more interested in the latter.
This is a chief reason why one group is for it and the other is against it. It's not that liberals don't think welfare fraud exists at all, they just don't think it's a big problem compared to the good such programs do. And it's not that conservatives don't think such programs do help some deserving poor people, they just hate the thought of some of their tax money going to someone mooching off the system.
- aidos 12y agoI'd hope that most conservatives don't attach that justification to welfare cuts. You effectively said that they would be happy to punish the vulnerable to ensure that those taking advantage of the system would also be punished. I Am Not A Conservative, but I'm fairly sure most of them would be horrified with that categorisation. I didn't downvote you, I do agree that you can't just say one or other thing is objectivley better. I think your example missed the mark though.
- sjtrny 12y agoIncreasing welfare will likely improve the lives of those who are using it, including those who are taking advantage of it. You did not disprove my point at all.