2 ms·
This is very inaccurate. It invents splits in Judaism (for example) that simply don't exist. For example it has a bizarre split of Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai
by ars 12y ago
This is very inaccurate. It invents splits in Judaism (for example) that simply don't exist.
For example it has a bizarre split of Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai and even more bizarrely continues the lines to modern times as if there are actually two separate branches.
When the parts that I know best are inaccurate, it seems likely to me that everything else will be just as bad.
- wbillingsley 12y agoIt seems to be attempting to list the church organisations rather than the faiths -- for instance, the Anglicans and Presbyterians have an entry for each country. If you were to list the faiths, you would have something very much smaller.
- a_c_s 12y agoEven so, the part on Judaism (about which I have the most knowledge) is still highly inaccurate: marking divisions that do not exist, branching in the wrong places, over-branching in some places, under-branching in others. It seems like an compelling idea undertaken by somebody vastly under qualified to implement it properly. (Which is not altogether surprising given the enormity of the task)
- larsiusprime 12y agoThere's a similar thing going on with other traditions -- with Eastern Orthodoxy, a lot of the various national jurisdictions (Russian, Greek, etc) are listed out separately even though (most) of them are in full communion with one another. It is cool to see all the "branches" laid out like this but it does lend itself to presenting more divisions than are actually there because that's what we naturally think of when we see a tree structure.