4 ms·
"In the meantime, several issues still need to be addressed. It is not yet clear how insurance companies might cover self-driving vehicles, for instance, or whe
by protomyth 12y ago
"In the meantime, several issues still need to be addressed. It is not yet clear how insurance companies might cover self-driving vehicles, for instance, or where blame would be attributed in a road accident."
Who is responsible is going to be the big make / break for all self-driving vehicles. I get the feeling this is going to be very messy.
- the8472 12y agoWhy not simply agree on a certain accident-rate with the insurance company and they cover anything that stays within that rate as long as there isn't any gross negligence - which would be pretty hard to prove, considering that the software can be audited in advance - or malicious behavior (kill 10 kids every christmas as long as we stay within the agreed rate). I mean smoothing out low-incidence, high-impact events is pretty much their business, no?
- derefr 12y agoBut insurance companies are founded on the assumption that they will only have to pay out in the exceptional case, no? If they can know for a fact that a certain accident rate is guaranteed for a given car, then they will explicitly disclaim liability for accidents within that rate, similar to how all product warranties expire before the far end of the bathtub curve. Otherwise it's like selling flood insurance on a flood plain, or health insurance to cancer patients: something that makes no economic sense and only exists where the government has forced it to.
- anigbrowl 12y agoNo they won't; they'll be happy to cover it because they'll know who to recover from. At bottom insurance is a cash-flow management business. They know very well what the probabilities are and build those into the price.
- the8472 12y ago> But insurance companies are founded on the assumption that they will only have to pay out in the exceptional case, no? "Exceptional case" is still a well-defined rate for them. They calculate risks and adjust insurance premium accordingly. That's pretty much their business. With sufficiently large amount of insured parties those "exceptional events" are actually fairly common. And that's what I was referring to. If the insurance company is in the business of calculating incident rates anyway they might as well cooperate with the autonomous car manufacturer to drive down incidence rates to a covered level. Just like car insurances will offer reduced premiums to experienced, accident-free drivers they can offer reduced fees to vehicle manufacturers who statistically cause fewer accidents.
- jabgrabdthrow 12y agoEverything has a guaranteed failure rate higher than 0, so is all insurance unprofitable? The warranty example is bad because warranties end instead of getting renewed. They'd happily renew the insurance for the cost of a new product minus epsilon.
- NeutronBoy 12y agoI don't always understand this POV. My current car has radar guided cruise control and auto braking - if these fail, who's responsible? Isn't auto-driving cars the same thing on a larger scale?
- gsnedders 12y agoYou have controls to override the car if they fail and you shouldn't be purely relying on them, so you're at fault. If you don't have any means to override them and you're expected to purely rely on them, surely you can't be at fault because what could you have done?
- trimble-alum 12y agoA fully-loaded, double trailer is an nearly unstoppable killing machine in traffic if it's not managed well.
- NeutronBoy 12y agoHow do I override the automatic brakes if they decide to engage while I'm driving down the freeway?
- gsnedders 12y agoI always assumed it was similar to cruise-control insofar as it can be turned off?
- JumpCrisscross 12y agoSuppose 100% of the responsibility is borne by manufacturers. How is this different from adaptive cruise control or ABS today? For one, the liability cross-section increases dramatically. In 2013, the U.S. auto insurance industry incurred $125 billion in damages [1]. With human error eliminated, this number will shrink. But it will also shift to manufacturers' balance sheets. What about insurance? Insurance works with un-correlated risks. You mowing down a pedestrian doesn't cause everyone around you to do the same. This keeps insurance companies' instantaneous expected losses manageable. Coding errors and recalls are not un-correlated. If your car has an error, so does–likely–every other car in its run. This concentrates losses and makes them difficult to insure. There are solutions. But systems will need to be built to allocate risk. [1] http://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/auto-insurance http://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/auto-insurance
- anigbrowl 12y agoI don't think that's going to be that big of an issue. From insurers' point of view, the probabilities of where fault might lie are highly predictable from past actuarial data - ie you could make a good guess about what percentage of accidents were caused by commercial vehicles being hit, or by mechanical failure, or by poor maintenance and so on, so as to isolate the driver as a factor. As soon as data is available showing that a computer-based driver is significantly safer than a human one, this is going to be reflected in the cost of insurance and will exert inexorable commercial pressure to automate driving wherever possible and make human control the exception. It works out OK for everyone; for insurers, a software error is the liability of a large firm with deep pockets, from whom up-front costs can be recovered, as opposed to irresponsible or inadequate human drivers whose personal assets may not cover the loss. From the software vendors' point of view, actuarial data provides very clear targets to shoot for, as well as a lot of data about the financial cost of failures. It's OK to take cost factors into account from an ethical standpoint as long as they're used to maximize safety by efficiently allocating resources, rather than to minimize production cost.
- deegles 12y agoIf a licensed mechanical engineer signs off on a set of building plans and the building collapses, they are held responsible. Should software for self driving cars be held to a similar standard?
- gregpilling 12y agoWhat is the current liability of software engineers in human life dependent programming? Was there any liability to the persons who wrote the Toyota code ? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9440094 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9440094
- afarrell 12y agoThe Therac-25 might be a better example than the Toyota code: http://sunnyday.mit.edu/papers/therac.pdf http://sunnyday.mit.edu/papers/therac.pdf
- jfoster 12y agoThere's a lot of potential for autonomous vehicles to have a black box that records everything that happened in the case of an accident. It may make it much clearer who is at fault in accidents. With driving being a repetitive task requiring attention and sometimes quick responses, I'm going to bet that in most cases it will be a human at fault.
- brc 12y agoYou don't have to have 'at fault' on order to have insurance. Insurance responds to the rules of the game. If the rules of the game are that damages from autonomous vehicles are capped, or that multi-vehicle collisions automatically share costs, then the cost of the insurance premium will adjust to that reality. It takes a leap of thinking to get away from the current obsession with precisely allocating fault in vehicle accidents, but it's entirely possible to do. Out of all the issues, insurance is the easiest one to solve.