4 ms·
If you are not interested in a physician's help, do not seek their help. If you are interested in a physician's help but do not want to take a specific medicat
by carbocation 11y ago
If you are not interested in a physician's help, do not seek their help.
If you are interested in a physician's help but do not want to take a specific medication or class of medications, things will get a bit more complex, but you should eventually be able to find a specialist who will work within the confines of your requests. However, limiting your treatment options in this way is hopefully not done lightly. Most of the medications that we have to offer do nothing for most people who take them. Abilify is one example, but it's not really unique in this way.
If you are interested in a physician's help but do not want to take a specific medication, yet your physician is insistent, it's not helpful to lie to your physician to get out of it. I think it would make sense to seek a second opinion or transfer your care to someone with whom you can negotiate, rather than lying about trying a medication. What's worse (for you) is that when you've finally had enough of this physician's lack of success and you move your care elsewhere, your new physician will think you have already tried a medication that you have not in fact tried, and so they will form an incorrect view of what did and did not work for your condition.
In sum, be honest with your doctor about what you suffer, what you take, and what you want; if you feel that you cannot negotiate honestly with your doctor, keep looking until you find someone with whom you are willing to be open.
- abecedarius 11y agoThis advice assumes you have the power to say no. If you might get committed, it seems sensible to consider all your options.
- carbocation 11y agoThe barrier to being "committed" is extremely high. Getting committed generally requires a patient to endorse a desire and a plan to harm themselves, or to temporarily be so disorganized that they cannot safely be in the community. The author does endorse a history of suicidality, but the description of the relationship with Abilify comes across as one where it is being offered in the context of a depression relapse. If she had voiced concerns in her article that she would be committed if she didn't try Abilify, that would be germane, but the article didn't seem to raise such concerns.
- meowface 11y agoIf a doctor is actually trying to commit someone who is not exhibiting any sort of psychotic symptoms, they should have their license revoked. I doubt the author would have gotten committed simply for being depressed and refusing to take an antipsychotic.