4 ms·
I was under the impression that the primary reason why charities did donation matching was to allow them to take money from major donors to fund projects while
by saurik 12y ago
I was under the impression that the primary reason why charities did donation matching was to allow them to take money from major donors to fund projects while still maintaining their public charity status by having widespread support from the public: if a small charity wants to accept a million dollars from some large company, they need to come up with half a million dollars donated by a number of small donors to pass the "public support test"; doing this per dollar instead of per commitment leads directly to "we can accept up to two dollars from this large donor for every dollar all of you small donors are able to contribute".
- cdcarter 12y agoThis may be true for MAJOR capital campaigns, but in my experience is rarely what motivates a matching campaign. At least in the size orgs I work with (1-2mil), matching campaigns are either genuine challenges from a donor OR a move to get the year-to-date number up to where it should be.
- saurik 12y agoCases where the challenge come from the donor don't seem to fall under the scope of the OP's strategy: a donor's challenges would be evaluated on benefit to the donor, maybe in terms of marketing their brand to the community, as opposed to how it affects donations. As you use the word "genuine" for that case, maybe the idea of whether matching grants are "effective" or not is simply an incorrect question?
- cdcarter 12y agoI personally am aware of more matching challenges and capping grants that are as I say "genuine". You make a good point, perhaps their efficacy is more aptly measured on the outcomes of the major donor. However, it's still a commonly held belief in resource development and fundraising that a match is a very strong motivator to give. This is a good start to determining how true that is. The OPs suggestion of heavily studying your own matching strategy and running different types is good advice (though maybe not 100% practical).
- cdcarter 12y agoI'll also note that I couldn't find any particular data on the efficacy of a match in large campaign fundraising vs. in-room fundraising. it's very different to see a match in a direct mail or general campaign, vs. say a featured guest at a fundraising party challenging the room personally.
- benkuhn 12y agoYeah, I definitely think donation matching is generally a good deal from the charity's perspective. When I wrote this I was more thinking from the perspective of someone who has a large fixed donation and is deciding what to do with it. In that case, they might want to back a matching campaign, but if they're trying to maximize the impact of their donation, they would want to know whether such a campaign would actually draw out more donations.