3 ms·
I have seen the situation from the other side and it seems to align somewhat with the idea of "don't disagree with the boss": I (Australian, white male) was co
by stephenr 12y ago
I have seen the situation from the other side and it seems to align somewhat with the idea of "don't disagree with the boss":
I (Australian, white male) was contracting for a telecom and my direct manager was an Indian guy. At one point, he said something technical and I disagreed and told him he's wrong.
He just said "ok then", turned around and went back to work. He didn't speak to me for three days (we sat next to each other) after that, even when I asked if he had anything for me to work on (a simple no without looking at me).
Eventually I had to call my contact at the contracting agency, who in turn contacted the manager.
The first thing he said to me? "If you have a problem you don't talk to him, you talk to me". The irony apparently was lost on him. The whole reason for the silent treatment was because I dared to dispute what he said in the office where other people (who we didn't work with directly) might hear. He admitted I was right but said I shouldn't have called him on it "in public"
Between that and "if the CEO is in the office you should be, so he knows you are working" the experience was not exactly great.
- victorhn 12y agoI think this is independent of culture. Being challenged by a person low on the hierarchy so openly does look untactful on your part.
- stephenr 12y agoI don't think you understand. Or if you do, we have very different ideas about what's important. He was my direct manager, but we were literally a team of two, working on a project together. He was unabashedly wrong - not slightly wrong, not a bit confused, not misinterpreted - just flat out wrong. When I told him, I didn't make a fuss, I didn't make a big deal, I just told him calmly "no, that's wrong, X because Y". Literally my only other option was to say nothing, and let the project waste time because of his incorrect assumptions/ideas.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- stephenr 12y agoIt was some technical detail about browser cookies. I don't remember what. But it was hardly the height of computer science. Regardless of whether he considered what I said to be tactful or not - a 3 day silent treatment broken only by a contract representative is a ridiculous response. My real point though is that he (and a lot of people) are more concerned with appearances than with actual good results. This relates to the term I used in another HN thread - the Kumbaya Approach to project management.