4 ms·
The transition from the first stage to the second is well known to be rather traumatic, with the dreaded “proof-type questions” being the bane of many a maths u
by analog31 12y ago
The transition from the first stage to the second is well known to be rather traumatic, with the dreaded “proof-type questions” being the bane of many a maths undergraduate.
I was fortunate that my K-12 math curriculum included proofs and derivations. We learned about sets in first grade. This was a suburban public school using textbooks from a mainstream publisher, in the 70s. Likewise college physics. As a result, there was no transition, and my college math grades went up when the courses were primarily about proofs.
It seems like a couple of things have happened since then, good and bad. What constitutes "math" has been reformulated to give kids a better chance of learning it. In my generation, we did proofs, but it was OK if 90% of the students failed to learn math at all. Math has multiple roles in society, as do science and computer programming, and preparing kids for professional careers in those subjects is not the only reason to teach them.
On the other hand, "math" has also been reformulated to manipulate standardized test scores.
- clebio 12y agoI may have inadvertantly down-voted when I meant to up-vote, because mobile phone interfaces are still terrible. HN doesn't let me change the vote. So I want to apologize and say that your comment is spot-on. There's a lot of specifics I'd reply to... if I was at my computer.
- analog31 12y agoNo prob. Thanks!
- fsk 12y agoIt sounds like they need a UI change for mobile. It should be upvote arrow, username, downvote arrow instead of the way it is now Then there would be no accidental downvotes.
- clebio 12y agoYeah, or like on the Stack Exchange sites, where you can undo the actions.
- keithpeter 12y ago1970s UK: we had the Schools Maths Project (SMP) GCE A level syllabus and textbooks available for teachers to choose which used sets, mappings, very simple group theory and the notion of an inverse and an identity for operations and which included computational approaches (pseudocode!) and a lot of emphasis on reasoning and proving. There were plenty of more 'traditional' syllabuses (syllabi?) available as well. My secondary school went for SMP maths (I suspect because the deputy principal was part of the project). I'm very glad they did. It helped later. A longitudinal survey of the destinations of those who did A level Maths in the 1970s tracking who did the SMP syllabus and who did a traditional syllabus might be interesting...
- james1071 12y agoI am not so convinced of the merits of SMP, having done it myself. It included some interesting things, but left out a lot of traditional pure and applied maths (especially mechanics).
- analog31 12y agoWhat happened in the US during my generation, was that every student with an interest in math, also took physics. And physics was very much taught as applied math.
- keithpeter 12y agoHave you ever missed the mechanics? The group theory stuff made things a lot easier for me later. I imagine this is all fairly random.