3 ms·
So what is the reasonable repeatable way to determine or gauge valuation? From what we have seen it is "Investor A wants X% of B and is willing to pay Z for it
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
So what is the reasonable repeatable way to determine or gauge valuation?
From what we have seen it is "Investor A wants X% of B and is willing to pay Z for it" therefore value is the multiple of Z that equals 100%. AkA Whatever someone will pay for it, AkA market prices. Except it's rarely a market in the traditional sense as it's really ever only a handful of buyers and they value it based on god knows what metrics.
Seems flimsy and based on whatever the most recent investor thinks - due diligence best practices aside.
We need a standard way to determine valuation so that founders and investors alike can point to something that is based in reality and can't be gamed as easily.
- netcan 12y agoDemanding a standard way to determine valuation is in some ways like demanding a standard way of coming up with ideas. The reason prices are determined this subjectively is because information is incomplete. That means you need to use a lot more one off judgements that can't be fit into a standard. If information was better then there would already be useful standards. There are pretty decent standards for companies that demonstrate a lot of consistency, like shipping companies. There are ways for valuing stock. On the other end of the spectrum, valuing a company that is still a work in progress is a different kind of problem. The upside is bigger and the downside more likely.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoThe reason prices are determined this subjectively is because information is incomplete. That is every market ever. No entity makes decisions based on perfect information - but plenty have a process that is auditable and lays out the assumptions. If information was better then there would already be useful standards. I think whatever standard or process we did come up with would be more refined/accurate with more information - but I that doesn't preclude having something that can be audited. I'm not saying that the process would spit out the "right" valuation, because that is impossible to tell prior to a liquidation event. What I am saying is that the process for determining valuations needs to be 100% more transparent. Like it or not there is a process - maybe it's all in one principle's head, but it's there. We as founders need to know what that is.