9 ms·
UN Experts Say TPP and Fast Track Threaten Human Rights
- javajosh 12y agoThere is a chapter in The Two Towers called "The Voice of Saruman". Saruman is defeated, but is still powerfully persuasive. At one point he calls to Gandalf and invites him into Orthanc. Those who hear the invitation believe that Gandalf will go into the tower to confer with Saruman, and will then emerge again to tell everyone their fate. Instead of doing that, Gandalf laughs, insults Saruman, and breaks his fucking staff.
- mark_l_watson 12y agoOne of the things I most like about the EFF is that they increase the transparency of back room deals that help special interests to the detriment of the general public. A little off topic, but in the last day I have found two public data sites that increase transparency in government finances at the local, state, and federal level: http://www.statedatalab.org http://www.statedatalab.org and http://www.truthinaccounting.org http://www.truthinaccounting.org
- thangalin 12y agohttps://bitbucket.org/djarvis/world-politics/wiki/Related https://bitbucket.org/djarvis/world-politics/wiki/Related Jump to "Government Tracking" and "Education" for more related links.
- mpyne 12y agoI can see how TPP (when we find out what precise it is) could be claimed to affect human rights. But "fast track" is a parliamentary technique used for other types of bills, such as the BRAC bills that are used to close U.S. military bases (domestically and overseas). Do things like BRAC also threaten human rights?
- wodencafe 12y agoI think you missed the point, which is Fast Tracking prevents proper debate and discussion of an issue from taking place, or severely limits it.
- mpyne 12y agoMy understanding is that Fast Track prevents amending a bill endlessly, not that it simply prevents debate. Is that not the case?
- kristopolous 12y agoOstensibly it puts the head of state in a power to negotiate with a guarantee that the legislative body won't modify the terms and conditions after the international negotiation is done. This offers a leveraging ability because the other negotiators know that the document won't be modified afterward. There's nothing wrong intellectually with the problem/solution scenario presented and solved by such a mechanism - so long as you entrust the people negotiating to be representing your interests. And therein lies the problem. Many American's haven't stated the words "This is not a representative government and has lost its authority" because that is directly seditious, but in practice their contextualized actions support this postulation. The reason that the mechanism of fast track is not ok because people strongly distrust the government - in fact, that's a redeeming feature of some open democracies - it's why we have an election determined by a calendar, and not the whim of the ruling party. The underpinnings of trust in what makes such a solution work is fundamentally incompatible with our structure and experience of government. We have strong evidence and are fully aware of what that will lead to. And as more of the TPP is leaked, we see we are 100% right. That's why fast track is patently offensive - we know it's the 1% trying to be a stealthy ninja to screw over the 99% even more. Well, most of us do --- some of us are Lenin's useful idiots (usually about 28% believe in supply side neoliberalism in polls. Lucky for us, about 90% of those hate Obama) This is why commercial news outlets report so little about it. A strategy of silence is the only chance they have. They could try to stall two years and hope a republican or at least a white male is in the white house but I think there is cognizance that the timeline of net neutrality which led to an activist victory can't be repeated. If you give the internet 2 more years to mobilize on this, TPP iz getting defeated. Chelsea Manning changed the rules of the game. People could relate to the wussy kid who shook the global military complex. Everything took off after that. Corporate power needs to be faster and quieter, the lion has awoken.
- jayvanguard 12y agoIn 30 years, with the benefit of hindsight, this could turn out to be one of the defining issues of our era (along with surveillance and the growth of state and corporate cyber warfare). Glad the UN and EFF are doing something to shine a light on it.
- wpietri 12y agoThe TPP makes me crazy, as I'm a big fan of trade for basically the same reason I'm a big fan of transparency: I think things generally go better when we have a lot of well-informed individuals thinking and making choices. I've been strongly in favor of pretty much every trade deal to come along. But here my feeling is more "fuck that" as I have zero faith that the secretive TPP process would produce anything I can trust.
- themartorana 12y agoAnd that's the rub, right? You agree with most prior free trade deals because you're privy to the information needed to form an opinion about them. You and I may disagree, but we have access to the facts in order to have informed debate. Keeping things secret can only be done because access to those facts would be almost universally distasteful to everyone - so let's not tell anyone. (It's easy to then make a jump to human rights, as violations of those are almost always secret.)
- anigbrowl 12y agoThose other trade deals were negotiated in secret before being presented to Congress for a vote, or to the public if it was a simple bilateral agreement without treaty powers. Do we negotiate nuclear policy iwth Iran on live TV with a big audience in the room? Of course not. Do we negotiate clogal warming agreements in public? No. The whole point of international negotiation is to sit down and be able to work out your differences in a de-politicized manner and then submit an agreement to legislatures for approval. I swear, I've never seen so much paranoid bullshit as I have about his TPP thing. This is diplomacy, not fucking reality TV.
- themartorana 12y agoNuclear agreements that deal with nations' rights to defend themselves on a level that could wipe out all life on Earth is so far and away different from trying to secretly enshrine universally disliked copyright laws for monetary protectionism, that it's mind-numbing that you would leave a comment with such snark while lacking any ability to differentiate between the topic we're dealing with and nuclear proliferation. The TPP is aggressively trying to enshrine SOPA-esque laws on the international level - laws that have repeatedly been defeated by almost universal public outcry. The fact that they're reintroduced in secrecy, as a method to circumvent the will of nations of people is where the hate for the TPP comes from.
- borrowedhour 12y agoIt's incredulous that Obama is pushing this deal so hard after backing net neutrality so early on when this deal is universally frowned upon. Not able to wrap around my head around this.
- mkempe 12y agoObama appears to have abandoned any pretense that he supports good, long-term political goals: drone wars, enabling Iran's nuclear ambitions, abandoning Ukraine, mass surveillance of the American and other people, letting ISIS take over much of Irak, secret anti-freedom trade agreements, pouring oil on local riots or crimes, avoiding "Je suis Charlie" demo, etc. The infamous words of a French king come to mind.
- jimrandomh 12y agoDo you know if Obama's involved (or for that matter, fully aware)? This seems like something that would mostly unfold at a lower level.
- atom-morgan 12y agoEnough to talk about it at Nike.
- briandear 12y agoHe's absolutely involved. He's the President. If he opposed this, he could fire anyone he wanted. Also, several aspects of thes negotiations are classified which would make it unlikely that any of this originated at a 'lower level.' The U.S. Trade represenative is an ambassador level appointment which means he was hand-picked by Obama. If this lack of transparency bothers you then you should be voting for Rand Paul or Ted Cruz and against Hilary Clinton. Remember Clinton has been the queen of opacity in terms of releasing information to the public. With Clinton, government will run like this as a default. She stonewalls at Congressional investigations, destroys email servers that could be evidence in criminal investigations.. And on and on. Almost anyone is better in terms of secrecy and disclosure than a Clinton. Obama is a close second: the closed door everything about this administration is disgusting; additionally his appointment of Loretta Lynch as AG is especially horrible considering her views on civil asset forfeiture. I think the Chinese Central Committee has more transparency than the Obama administration.
- jimrandomh 12y ago> They allow investors to sue nations over legislative and administrative rules alleging that they harm their profits. This is much bigger than copyright. This is removing substantive power from existing governments and transferring it to a new structure. The fast-tracking should be seen, not just as evading scrutiny by the public, but also as evading scrutiny by Congress and by other legislatures whose power is being stolen from them. When you write your representative, you might warn them that this puts them on track to end up like the Queen of England: powerless figureheads.
- themartorana 12y agoYou imagine those writing this deal are giving away their power. I rebut with, if the government wasn't already a mouthpiece for mega corps, the deal would never be written to begin with. Now that business owns government, it makes sense for them to start transforming it to a more directly profitable model.
- jpollock 12y agoThe goal of those sections of the agreement are to force governments to treat foreign investment the same as if it had arrived from a resident. The intent is to stop things like what happens in South America, where they look around, see an oil company sitting there that is majority foreign owned and nationalise it to fix a balance of payments issue[2]. Some organisations (like Philip Morris) will try to use it as a hammer, but that's because anyone can sue. The US is already party to similar agreements - NAFTA being one. They've even got a standard set of terms for them [1]. First world countries with strong court systems already have these protections in place. This is aimed at other countries who don't have quite as strong a rule of law. As for secrecy... Just because congress gives the President fast-track negotiation rights doesn't mean that the deal has to pass. It just means that congress has to have a straight up or down vote on it, without amendments. There will still be time to review and debate it. Agreements are negotiated in secret. Can you imagine a trade agreement negotiated in the current US Congress? [1] http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/188371.pdf http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/188371.pdf [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrobras#Bolivian_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrobras#Bolivian_controversy
- jbuzbee 12y agoI'm all for free trade. Who could be for protectionism and artificial constraints on basic economic forces? But free trade, the TPP ain't: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150422/23441830765/if-you-really-think-tpp-is-about-trade-then-your-analysis-is-already-wrong.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150422/23441830765/if-yo...
- maceo 12y agoWho could be for protectionism? Well for starters, the United States for most of its history. Protectionism is a big part of what put the US in a position to become the global superpower. Tariffs on superior, imported textiles from the British Empire allowed the US textile industry to become dominant. Many years later the US gov did the same thing at the behest of the American steel magnates, allowing the US steel industry to become dominant. In fact, the GWB administration added tariffs to protect the US steel industry against Chinese steel about 10 years ago. Furthermore, just this week, US steel companies are asking to have them put back into place http://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-steel-ceo-says-tariffs-could-be-needed-on-chinese-imports-1430950792 http://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-steel-ceo-says-tariffs-could... . This is a case of the US advocating do as we say, not as we do. The US obviously doesn't want Vietnam, Mexico, or any other country to develop their own industries -- they want to flood their markets with American made products so that American corporations can see nice profits. Unfortunately, thats usually at odds with whats in the best interest of the foreign nations population.
- jbuzbee 12y agoNo arguments here. Lots of countries, the US included, have historically utilized protectionist polices that benefit local industries at the expense of higher prices for local citizens and undeserved profits for local industry. My point, besides the fact that I'm personally in favor of free trade, is that the TPP in reality has little to do with free trade. From an analysis by Dean Baker: "The actual trade barriers between the United States and the countries in these deals, with few exceptions, are already quite low. This means that there is little to be gained by lowering them still further." http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dean-baker/the-trade-agreement-pinat_b_6369924.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dean-baker/the-trade-agreement...
- davidu 12y agoTPA has been around for 30 years. It's always worked well. The idea is that congress sets a standard and set of parameters for negotiation that the US Trade Authority then goes out to negotiate and structure trade deals. They must stay within the boundaries set by congress. Then they can go out and negotiate in good faith, knowing that if they stay in those boundaries, congress has agreed to debate and then approve or reject a deal within 90 congressional days (about a year). The bar for rejection is high, because the deal in front of them has to already fit within the parameters congress themselves set out. The term "Fast Track" has to be one of the most misleading terms used in political lingo. Fast Track in this sense basically means almost a year for congress to approve a trade deal. Moreover, very little about TPP or Fast Track is "secret" or "backroom" and is how trade deals have been done for the longest time. It's unclear why the EFF is taking up this cause. This is also helpful, and is non-partisan congressional research funded by congress to surface the real facts: https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL33743.pdf https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL33743.pdf The amount of propaganda being spun up over TPA is surprising, considering we've had it for 30 years and it's been an economic boon for the US economy. Edit: I have no idea why I'm being downvoted for this.
- shit_parade2 12y agoSure, how about you link the draft then, otherwise stop spreading your lies.
- dang 12y ago> otherwise stop spreading your lies Personal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoThe fast track, that is taking congress a year to sign, is the process of not then needing congress to sign anything after. If it passes, the whitehouse will be able to then sign details of new trade agreements without congress. It is not not the initial process of getting congress to agree to fast track.
- 12y ago
- shit_parade2 12y agoWhat can people do about secret backroom deals? Honestly very little or just about nothing unless you have more money and influence than the mega corps who want this deal passed. No, what people can do is just ignore the law and defy the government, not like the government wields legitimate power anyway.
- arca_vorago 12y agoThis is the real problem that TPTB dont seem to grasp. If you make the rampant lawlessness visible to the people, the people will stop respecting the law. That is how societies fall apart, when the rule of law is a farce, you can expect nothing but strife.
- pekk 12y agoThe general complaint is that this isn't transparent, but it's fully within the law.
- johnnybowman 12y agoDevil's advocate here: - America already has low tariffs (hence our lust for imported goods). The rest of the world has higher tariffs. US goods producers stand more to gain from TPP than foreign goods producers. - Average wages for traded/export industries, such as Kentucky bourbon, are higher than for local industries, like hospitals. The more the US can focus on traded industries, the more wages rise in America. Germany does a great job of this. We don't but TPP would help. - TPP still has to get approved by Congress. Fast track just strips Congress' ability to amend or filibuster the deal - two tactics that favor special interests over majority interests. - Special interests are always powerful in trade negotiations. Limiting their power is crucial to passing equitable, long-term focused deals.
- o0-0o 12y agoGod's advocate here: I'd like to note that amendments are important, and taking away the ability to amend a bill is not a good thing. Take for example the 1st amendment to the constitution: Freedom of Speech.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>America already has low tariffs The TPP isn't about tarriffs. They're the smallest and least important part of the deal. >- Average wages for traded/export industries, such as Kentucky bourbon, are higher than for local industries, like hospitals. Survivorship bias. >- TPP still has to get approved by Congress. Fast track just strips Congress' ability to amend or filibuster the deal Fast track also legislates away Congress's own constitutional trade authority over future deals. Basically (Hillary) or whomever will be able to dictate what goes in future deals. >- Special interests are always powerful in trade negotiations. Limiting their power is crucial to passing equitable, long-term focused deals. It was drafted in complete secrecy by corporate lobbyists. It's their bill. It's their dream. Limiting the power of special interests like them means striking the bill down.
- smutticus 12y agoWe can't engage in any nuanced conversation of the TPP because we don't know what's in it. Given that, I find no reason to be anything but completely against it.
- Nursie 12y agoAnd don't forget TTIP, the euro side of this. It's the same idea (companies can sue governments for making laws that impact potential future earnings' amongst other things), and is being negotiated in the same secretive way, with even MEPs having to sign NDAs before being allowed to see a draft. Crazy.
- walterbell 12y agoFrom http://motherboard.vice.com/read/whoever-is-leaking-trans-pacific-partnership-drafts-please-leak-more http://motherboard.vice.com/read/whoever-is-leaking-trans-pa... "[TPP] .. stands to have intensely damaging effects on nearly every front, from internet freedom to copyright law. But if you raise these concerns with negotiators, who have privileged access to the text of the agreement, they’ll just tell you that they have access to the latest draft, and you don’t ... Every TPP chapter leaked reveals some new policy horrorshow. But in this game of cat and mouse between governments, corporations, and citizens, those who are in the know always have the upper hand."
- xnull2guest 12y agoHow can I come to these comments and not see a single thing written about China? Secretary of Defense Carter stated that he would rather have the TPP succeed than have another aircraft carrier. The TPP, from a national defense perspective, is one of the aces in the US sleeve. It is a way to isolate China, who would like to be a superpower, who has overtaken the US in terms of economic might, and who is challenging the US for geopolitical power, from the rest of the Asia-Pacific economy - unless it plays by a specific set of rules. Extremely strong exportation of US intellectual property law into the Asia-Pacific? Yeah, that has nothing to do with the battle for the new world and the past 16 years of US foreign policy to 'Pivot to Asia'. I'm not saying the TPP will be good for US citizens. I am saying that it will be one piece in something 'good' for the United States as a world power. It's true and unfortunate that what can be bad for one can be good for another. But let's call a spade a spade.
- themartorana 12y agoThe first interesting comment in "favor" (as in, a possible defense, not necessarily parent's opinions) of the TPP that make me step back and consider another angle. Of course, I still land in favor of a quick death to the TPP... China's global economic dominance is likely a foregone conclusion. More a question of "when" than "if..." I wouldn't mind getting on with the business of how the U.S. operates in an admirable 2nd place rather than living through even more international meddling that seems to universally bite us in the ass, eventually.
- xnull2guest 12y agoThis is what Washington Thinktanks and Defense Officials are saying about the TPP. I'm not really advocating the TPP as much as I am trying to bring awareness about what the TPP is for.
- contingencies 12y agoFirst, China is not the boogeyman. I've lived there for ages, the modern state is very decent by a lot of measures and you really do feel safer on the streets than in much of the western world. Yes, it has its problems, but at least it doesn't run around randomly invading countries, dreaming out loud about "instant global strike capability". China doesn't and will never play by US rules. For example, they joined the WTO and just ignored a lot of the provisions. This is a good thing for the world, because it keeps things multi-polar. The last thing we need is one world government with a corporate-dominated aggressor-state flush with dynastic influence determining world political and economic fate in an era where we are facing survival-level serious global issues. Einstein rightly said Nationalism is an infantile disease: the measles of mankind ... however, I'm sure he wouldn't have lobbied for the alternative of a shady back-channel network of non-transparent private supra-national political/economic paralegal rent-seeking and enforcement. That's essentially what we're heading toward, as Assange echoes: The world is not sliding, but galloping into a new transnational dystopia. http://cryptome.org/2012/12/assange-crypto-arms.htm http://cryptome.org/2012/12/assange-crypto-arms.htm You should consider broadening your conception of international happenings from American politics. US 'pivoted' as far as Taiwan, Korea and Japan with a fat military 60 years ago, now the dominant thinking in the region (with early indications led by New Zealand and elements of Australian politics) is that they can go and pivot back on home.
- blindblom 12y agoHow can a trade deal be negotiated transparently when our media circus will be out in force muddying the waters? If he (Obama) keeps the terms of the deal secret until its brought up for a vote, he's not being transparent. If he makes the current terms of negotiation transparent, how is any president supposed to negotiate terms with multiple foreign governments when the noise generated by the media circus, members of the house and senate, and various other talking-heads would constantly muddy the waters? Until the terms of the deal are known, I prefer to withhold judgement because even ordering from a drive-thru with a half-dozen children in the back of your car is difficult. I can't imagine the impossibility of negotiating a trade deal with Republicans and Rupert Murdock giving their play-by-play analysis every step of the way.
- pyre 12y agoThe terms of the TTP are so bad that they had to discuss it in secret, because otherwise people would be able to see all of the utter bullshit that it contains.