4 ms·
> Many people prefer bleeding edge. For me, I prefer Debian's definition of stable Having maintained Debian, Fedora, and ArchLinux machines over the past few y
by dmix 12y ago
> Many people prefer bleeding edge. For me, I prefer Debian's definition of stable
Having maintained Debian, Fedora, and ArchLinux machines over the past few years, I've found ArchLinux has vastly improved in terms of stability recently while still maintaining close to bleeding edge releases. I don't see it get enough credit for this. This must be the result of having a high quality team of package maintainers who know how to push out new packages properly.
Fedora on the other hand also promises bleeding edge - but for years I found it broke far too often, and yum is certainly not helpful in those situations.
As a result I no longer see it as a "bleeding edge vs stable" dichotomy. You can have your cake and eat it too if you a) choose your software stack wisely and b) use a distro with a smart team behind it. Switching to the Debian boxes always feels like stepping back 2yrs in a time machine, which has a high cost for a person who likes to keep up with progress in software development.
- rifung 12y agoHm interesting.. do you ever feel like you are missing out on any programs while on ArchLinux? It seems that when people want to support Linux they often only choose to support Ubuntu/Debian. I'm definitely tempted to give ArchLinux a try now though
- tormeh 12y agoThe great thing about Linux is that if some software supports one distro, then there's always a sane way to get it working on other distros.
- rifung 12y agoAh! Well, I suppose I was always afraid of having to mess with OS related stuff instead of getting things done but I think it's about time I learn. Thanks for the information!
- comex 12y agoOf course, there's also Debian unstable, which is, in fact, pretty darn stable. I don't maintain servers professionally, but I've been using Debian unstable personally for years, and rarely had problems.
- click170 12y ago> Switching to the Debian boxes always feels like stepping back 2yrs in a time machine, which has a high cost for a person who likes to keep up with progress in software development. (emphasis mine) It still feels like we're disagreeing because we have a different idea of what stable software is, yours is keeping up with progress in software development and mine is using software that's been tried and tested by many others first. If I may suggest, you may enjoy the Unstable or Testing Debian distributions the next time you're giving it a go, if you can get past the admittedly off-putting names. But further, are you suggesting that you can't keep up with progress in software development from a Debian Stable box? With apt-pinning, backports, and having the ability compile from source into .deb files, I have to disagree with you on this.
- keithpeter 12y agoManjaro is a derivative of Arch that includes repositories that are delayed for a few weeks to allow any occasional bugs to be caught. Manjaro Live ISOs provide an installer and hardware detection as well. Just in case anyone wants a play.